India terminates bilateral investment treaties (BITs)
Recently, India has terminated its bilateral investment treaties (BIT) with 57 countries, including the Netherlands. This means Dutch companies in India, and Indian companies in the Netherlands, can no longer make use of the controversial arbitration procedures called ISDS. According to Burghard Ilge from Both ENDS, India's action is a step in the right direction. However it is a missed opportunity that the Dutch government did not agree with this termination. This way, old investments stay protected for 15 years under the former BIT.
BITs are often detrimental for developing countries, as they provide extensive protection for foreign investors through the ISDS arbitration procedures. Investors who believe they are effected by policy changes can claim billions from the state. "This gives businesses an undesirable power position," says Burghard Ilge. "Companies can put pressure on governments and frustrate legislation, which is often urgently needed to better protect people and the environment."
By unilaterally canceling 57 BITs, not only with the Netherlands but also with the United Kingdom, France, Germany and Spain, India has taken significant steps to mitigate this ISDS system. With consent of the Netherlands, the risky old investment treaty could have been completely disabled. As the Netherlands have failed to do so, the old treaty remains valid for another 15 years for investments done before December 2016. This was a bad surprise for Burghard Ilge: "Previously, the Dutch government stated that such BITs are undesirable. By agreeing to the termination of the treaty between India and the Netherlands, we would have dismissed the whole contract at once."
Meanwhile, negotiations are being held about a new investment treaty between India and the European Union, which has taken over this responsibility from the member states. India has set up a new model BIT, which is a significant improvement, according to Burghard Ilge. "Yet, the changes are not enough. It still contains ISDS in some way, and in Both ENDS' view ISDS should be taken out completely. A new approach in investment treaties is necessary. We will continue to watch the negotiations and share our analysis of the treaty with policymakers and NGOs in both the Netherlands and India when necessary. We would rather not see any new agreement in this form."
Read more about this topic:
- Launch of new book 'Rethinking Bilateral Investment Treaties' (16 March 2016), Both ENDS
- What do bilateral investment treaties actually offer us? (21 september 2015), Both ENDS
- To change a BIT is not enough (21 September 2015), Both ENDS
- Socialising losses, privatising gains: how Dutch investment treaties harm the public interest (January 2015), SOMO, Both ENDS, Milieudefensie, TNI
Read more about this subject
-
Dossier /
Towards a socially and environmentally just energy transition
To address the climate crisis we need to urgently transition away from fossil fuels towards clean, renewable energy. However, this transition is not only about changing energy sources. It requires an inclusive and fair process that tackles systemic inequalities and demanding consumption patterns, prioritizes environmental and social justice, and which does not repeat mistakes from the past.
-
Blog / 30 January 2025
Brumadinho’s painful “seas of mud”
By Carolina de Moura
Six years ago, Brumadinho tailings dam I, from the Paraopeba Complex, owned by mining company Vale, collapsed. January 25th, 2019, forever changed the lives of thousands. The scars remain open, and the quest for justice, remembrance, and prevention of future mining crimes endures despite all adversities. This was manslaughter coupled with socio-environmental devastation of proportions difficult to measure. These are irreparable losses and damages that could have been avoided if it wasn’t for the greed, negligence, and irresponsibility of decision-makers at Vale, the German certification firm Tüv Süd, and the state of Minas Gerais.
-
Blog / 28 January 2025
Sinking promises in Manila
Yesterday, Global Witness published a new report, "Sunk Costs" - in which I had a modest role to play - that comes up with new facts about the disastrous New Manila International Airport project in the Philippines, for which the Dutch dredging multinational Boskalis received Dutch export credit insurance (ekv) of €1.5 billion.
-
News / 22 January 2025
-
Publication / 16 January 2025
-
News / 16 January 2025
DetoX: Both ENDS leaves X
Both ENDS, along with many other Dutch organisations, is leaving social media platform X. In January, we will join the campaign ‘#DetoX’ by De Goede Zaak and Stem op een Vrouw. We hope that many organisations will follow us so that the hate, misinformation and the undermining of democracy on X are given less space.
-
News / 13 January 2025
New partnership with Netherlands Enterprise Agency for resilient food systems in Sahel
The situation in Africa's Sahel is the world's fastest-growing humanitarian crisis. Over 3 million people are fleeing violence. They are ravaged by hunger, disease and increasing drought caused by climate change. Both ENDS and its partners are successfully working on accelerating the resilience of local food systems and communities in the Sahel, based on ‘Farmer Managed Natural Regeneration’ (FMNR). The project, funded by DOB Ecology, will end in mid-2026, but has already been followed up thanks to a new collaboration with the Netherlands Enterprise Agency (RVO).
-
Publication / 9 January 2025
-
Publication / 8 January 2025
-
Publication / 7 January 2025
-
Video / 6 January 2025
-
Publication / 6 January 2025
-
Publication / 6 January 2025
-
Publication / 3 January 2025
-
Video / 3 January 2025
Dare to Trust: Jarai Women of Cambodia
With the Dare to Trust grant, the Taing Se Malu organization decided to purchase pigs that can be raised and increased in quantities by the women members of their organization. More importantly, through the grant, they formed a women’s group and a youth group to empower them in their pursuit of a more gender-just community.
-
Video / 3 January 2025
Dare to Trust: the Tumandok Women from the Philippines
With resources that the ATBBB women's group received for their Dare to Trust-project, they decided to move forward with growing, processing and selling what they have at their disposal: coffee. They created a production center for their community based enterprise.
-
Video / 3 January 2025
NTFP-EP Asia supports women's groups with Dare to Trust-grants
NTFP-EP Asia has given small grants to two grassroots women’s organisations in the Philippines and Cambodia. These grants are part of our Dare to Trust project, a pilot with unconditional funding supported by the Dutch Postcode Lottery.
-
Publication / 23 December 2024
-
Video / 23 December 2024
Dare to Trust: LILAK supports women to start sustainable agriculture
Indigenous women in Didipio, Philippines, grew close to each other when confronting the mining corporation OceanaGold. Now they continue their struggle collectively in the women's group "Bileg Daggiti Babbai". With the help of LILAK they started a sustainable farming project, which helps them make a living to support their day to day needs and afford their children's education.
The project was made possible in Both ENDS's Dare to Trust project, supported by the Dutch Postcode Lottery.
-
Publication / 23 December 2024