Local leaders want Dutch effort for sustainable palm oil production
Over the past 15 years the production of palm oil has increased enormously, and not without reason: palm oil, pressed from the fruit of the oil palm, is cheap and is used in many different products. It is processed in ice cream, chocolate, margarine and sauces, but also in personal care products and cosmetics such as lipstick, detergent, toothpaste, soap and biofuel. Unfortunately, the large demand for palm oil has quite some negative side effects: large-scale deforestation, pollution, 'land grabbing' and above all human rights violations are common practice in countries where palm oil is produced.
The delegation on the 'Maasvlakte' near Rotterdam, where the palm oil enters Europe to be processed.
On Friday the 29th of April, an international delegation of four local leaders from Indonesia, Colombia and Liberia visited the Ministry of Foreign Affairs in The Hague to discuss the consequences of the large scale palm oil industry in their region.The meeting was part of a European tour, organised by the 'Forest Peoples Programme' (FPP). Both ENDS organised the Dutch part of the tour in collaboration with Oxfam Novib, SOMO and TNI. In The Hague, the delegation spoke with policy makers, industry, financiers and NGOs about concrete measures and actions to be taken and supported by the Netherlands to improve the situation in the producing regions.
Palm oil mark
These days, around 40 % of all palm oil entering Europe comes from Indonesia. "In Indonesia, an area of 6 million hectares, which is almost twice the Netherlands, is already converted into palm oil plantations. And this area will only increase in the coming years. The Indonesian government wants to double the current production of 40 million tons to 80 million tons by 2020", says Sanderijn van Beek of Both ENDS. This rapid expansion of oil palm plantations has a huge impact on the communities and their environment. The forest, which millions of people directly depend upon for their livelihood, turn into endless monocultures of oil palm. The rich biodiversity disappears and surface and groundwater get contaminated by pesticides and fertilisers, which completely deplete the soil. As palm oil is so profitable, its production is expanding to Latin America and Africa. In countries such as Colombia and Liberia forested area's and other land is rapidly transformed into palm oil plantations.
One of the members of the delegation is Agus Sutomo, director of the NGO LINKAR Borneo from Indonesia: "The forest is our natural supermarket; it has been providing us with food and medicines for centuries. When the large-scale palm oil plantations came, the forest disappeared and people no longer have access to food. In addition, water sources are contaminated. We now eat 'instant noodles' and we earn too little on the plantation to let our children go to school." Palm oil production also comes with a lot of violence: too often, people are under great pressure to give up their land. Willian Aljure from Colombia, another delegation member, describes how nine of his relatives, including his mother, were brutally killed. Palm oil companies are not afraid of using brutal violence against those who protest against the conversion of their forest into a plantation. This often happens even with the support of local authorities, according to the testimonies.
Role of the Netherlands
The Netherlands is the largest importer of palm oil in Europe and the country wants to promote sustainable production and supply chains. In December 2015 the Dutch government took the initiative which led to the signing of the 'Amsterdam Declaration', in which the Netherlands and four other EU Member States declare to commit to a 100% sustainable palm oil production, in order to stop deforestation, pollution and human rights violations. The delegation of local leaders asked the Netherlands to make every effort to ensure that this declaration is not just a so-called paper tiger, but will result in binding legal measures.
Legal framework rather than non-binding promises
There are several initiatives to make the palm oil chain more sustainable, such as the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil, in which companies that are part of the palm oil supply chain, financial institutions and civil society organisations have united. Within this initiative, companies have to follow social and environmental rules, but participation remains voluntary and compliance to the rules is, in practice, difficult to enforce. All members of the delegation that came to Europe stressed that these voluntary initiatives lead to very few concrete improvements and that the rights of local communities are still not protected sufficiently. Agus Sutomo: "We need the global community to understand that when they are consuming palm oil and biofuels they are consuming the blood of our peoples in Indonesia, Liberia, Colombia and Peru." The delegation members, who feel the impact of the palm oil production in their daily lives, emphasise that governments should set strict requirements for palm oil entering the EU in order to better protect the rights of indigenous communities and the forests on which they depend.
Palm oil a biofuel?
The meeting was well attended. The intense testimonies of the members of the delegation showed how abuses and human rights violations continue in producing countries, despite certification and initiatives from the palm oil sector itself. Although well-intentioned and positive, these initiatives prove not to be sufficient to protect the rights of people and ecosystems. The visit comes at an important moment, as the Dutch government reviews the European energy policy. In order to meet European standards for renewable energy, palm oil is increasingly used as biofuel to partially replace fossil fuels. A larger demand for palm oil would only increase the problems around its production. We hope that the facts and arguments that have been brought to the table by the delegation, will be taken into account by policy-makers the discussions concerning palm oil.
About the members of the delegation (from FPP website):
- Franky Samperante is an indigenous representative from Sulawesi and is the founder-director of the indigenous peoples’ organisation Pusaka, which provides support to indigenous communities in Central Kalimantan, Indonesia. In 2014, Pusaka published an atlas detailing extensive palm oil land grabs on indigenous peoples’ lands in Papua and West Papua.
- Agus Sutomo is director of the Pontianak-based NGO LinkAR-Borneo, in West Kalimantan, Indonesia. The NGO works with communities whose lands have been taken over without their consent and helps them to file complaints with the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO)
- Ali Kaba is a program coordinator and senior researcher at the Sustainable Development Institute, a Liberian NGO working with rural communities in Liberia to protect their land in the face of ongoing, rapid large-scale land transactions.
- Willian Aljure is a human rights defender from the plains region of Colombia (Los Llanos). He was forcibly displaced from his home in Mapiripán, Meta, Colombia, and has since campaigned to retrieve family lands and community territories lost to oil palm expansion. He has received death threats which prevent him from returning home.
Read more about this subject
Event / 23 March 2023, 13:15 - 14:30
Making finance for gender just water and climate solutions a reality!
The UN Water Conference is an important event that brings together stakeholders from around the world to discuss water and climate solutions. This year, GAGGA is organizing a side event during the conference that you won't want to miss!
On Thursday March 23rd, from 1.15 -2.30 pm, GAGGA will present their commitment to support, finance, and promote locally rooted, gender just climate and water solutions within the Water Action Agenda. This event will inspire other stakeholders to join in their commitment, while presenting inspiring examples of such solutions presented by local women from Nepal, Kenya, Paraguay, Mexico, and Nigeria.
Event / 23 March 2023, 09:00 - 11:00
Towards just water governance in Colombia; a dialogue on the Transformative Water Pact
Online side event at the UN Water conference in New York
This event will present The Transformative Water Pact (TWP), an innovative framework for water governance that has been developed by environmental justice experts from around the world. The TWP will serve as a starting point for dialogue between representatives of the government of Colombia, academia, regional and international NGOs in relation to Colombia's current ambitions in multi-scalar water governance.
Publication / 21 March 2023
News / 21 March 2023
Agua es vida: Both ENDS and water governance
Water is literally life, the lifeblood of ecosystems, of nature, of humans. However, in many places the distribution and use of water is unjust and unsustainable. Water management is generally focused on short-term economic interests, on maximizing the profit of a well-connected few at the expense of people and nature. This dominant view of water and water management has its origins in the European industrial revolution, which became the global norm through colonialism and globalization. But according to Melvin van der Veen and Murtah Shannon, water experts at Both ENDS, this view will have to give way to equitable, sustainable and inclusive water management. Both ENDS cooperates with and supports communities and organisations worldwide who are working to this end.
Press release / 20 March 2023
A Transformative Water Pact : A radical response to the global water governance crisis
Academics and civil society representatives from around the world came together to articulate an alternative vision and framework for water governance, in the run-up to the UN Water Conference 2023 in New York. The Transformative Water Pact was developed in response to the continued exploitation of nature, neglect of human rights and the extreme power-imbalances that characterize contemporary water governance throughout the world. It details an alternative vision of water governance based on the tenets of environmental justice, equality and care.
Publication / 15 March 2023
Publication / 15 March 2023
Publication / 9 March 2023
Press release / 9 March 2023
Dutch Pension funds do not vote in line with climate ambitions
Most Dutch pension funds and their asset managers do not vote consistently in favour of climate resolutions at the oil and gas companies and banks in which they invest. That is the conclusion of a report published today by Both ENDS and Groen Pensioen. Eleven of the twelve* Dutch pension funds studied have made public statements and pledges about adapting their policies in line with the Paris Climate Agreement. But their voting behaviour does not sufficiently correspond with these pledges. Only pension fund PME votes for 100% in line with its own climate promises.
Publication / 9 March 2023
Event / 5 March 2023, 13:00
On Sunday March 5 Both ENDS will be joining the Feminist March (called Women's March before). It starts at 1 PM at De Dam in Amsterdam.
With our block "Feminists for Climate Justice" we'll gather in front of Madame Tussauds.
News / 4 March 2023
Op-ed: We can’t leave tackling the climate crisis to men
Make women and gender equality a priority in climate policy, wrote Rebecca Heuvelmans (Women Engage for a Common Future), Marjon Melissen (ActionAid), Esin Erdogan (Simavi), Annelieke Douma (Both Ends) and Eva Lia Colombo (Wo=men Dutch Gender Platform) in Dutch newspaper Trouw. Sunday March 5, they'll join the Feminist March in Amsterdam.
Event / 2 March 2023, 14:00 - 15:30
Inclusive finance for land governance: A conversation with donors
Both ENDS and the Land Portal Foundation invite you to the fourth webinar in the Whose Land? Inclusive Pathways to Land Governance series. This fourth Whose Land? webinar will focus on the question: How can donors fund land governance initiatives through an inclusive process?
More information about this event is available on Landportal.org
Letter / 28 February 2023
175 CSOs call on world leaders to end OECD export finance for oil and gas
This joint position launched by 175 civil society organisations from 45 countries calls on world leaders to end OECD export finance for oil and gas, and explains how it can be done.
News / 20 February 2023
Almost 60 organisations send a letter about fossil export support to Dutch Parliament
Today, a letter, undersigned by almost 60 organisations from countries that face the consequences of fossil fuel projects or stand in solidarity, has been sent to the Dutch Members of Parliament. This Thursday, a debate about the export credit facility and the policies around it, will take place in the Dutch Parliament. The coalition calls upon Dutch politicians and policy makers to stand up against any form of export support for fossil fuel projects that are to be executed by Dutch companies abroad, expecially in the global South.
Letter / 20 February 2023
Letter of international CSO's to Dutch Parliament: close gaps in Dutch policy on limiting public finance to fossil fuels
In October 2022, the Dutch government published a policy to implement the COP26 statement in which it promised to stop public finance for fossil fuel projects abroad by the end of 2022 . The proposed policy, unfortunately, has quite some 'loopholes' that make it possible for the Dutch government to keep supporting large fossil projects abroad for at least another year. These projects often run for years and will have a negative impact on the countries where they take place for decades to come.
News / 6 February 2023
Op-ed: Dutch construction project in the Philippines shows that voluntary corporate social responsibility doesn’t work
This op-ed was published in Dutch newspaper Trouw on the 3rd of February this year
Abuses committed during the construction of an airport in the Philippines show the urgent need for legislation on corporate social responsibility here in the Netherlands, say Murtah Shannon of Both ENDS and Maartje Hilterman of IUCN NL on behalf of a coalition of Dutch and Philippine organisations.
News / 5 February 2023
Using Philanthropy, Advocacy and More to Shift Power
(This interview was published on January 18th in Inside Philantrophy)
Most people in philanthropy don't enter the sector because they have dreams of working in a financial institution. But that's exactly what they're doing. The philanthropic sector as we know it today was deliberately designed by the robber barons of the early 19th century as a response to extreme wealth inequality they created through exploitative labor practices in the oil, steel and shipping industries. Whether to genuinely make amends for the harms they created or to engage in reputation washing, the industrialists cornered the market on philanthropy, guarding against legal challenges to its tax shelter functionality and curtailing regulatory legislation that could induce democratic decision-making. Today, the value of philanthropy stands at about $2.3 trillion, which is 3% of the global economy.
News / 10 January 2023
In Memoriam: Irene Dankelman
With pain in our hearts we say farewell to Irene Dankelman. She was pioneer in the field of gender and environment and one of the founders of Both ENDS.
Video / 31 December 2022
Let's work together towards a green, just and healthy 2023!
At Both ENDS, we were happy to finally be able to meet many of our partners again in 2022. Although digital meetings are here to stay, they will never beat a live encounter every once in a while where we get to know each other's contexts, learn from each other and motivate and inspire one another.
But be it live or online, together we will work towards a green, just and healthy 2023!