The palm oil dream: too good to be true
In 2005, a palm oil company approached the villagers of Kiungkang in West-Kalimantan, Indonesia, with offers to convert their farms to oil palm smallholdings. Many farmers agreed to the proposal because of the high monthly incomes promised by the company that they could earn from the oil palms. Unfortunately, the palm oil dream turned out to be an illusion.
In Kiungkang, the smallholder arrangement meant that the palm oil company whose concession surrounds the village, PT SML, planted oil palms on 100% of the land of farmers. The company incorporated 80% of this land into its own plantation, and the remaining 20% was left to be managed and harvested by the smallholders. The company would then buy the palm kernel harvested by the farmers on their 20% of the land. Depending on the size of their smallholding, farmers were told they could earn as much as 9 million Rupiah (± € 600) a month, almost twice the average income in Indonesia. A very promising prospect!
Smallholder incomes: not enough to live on
But when Both ENDS staff Roos Nijpels and Michael Rice visited the village with our partner organisation Link-AR Borneo, the smallholders told them a very different story. The farmers were obliged to sell their palm kernel to PT SML at rates determined by the company. Smallholders were also required to enter into unnecessary credit arrangements at high interest rates with PT SML to finance the planting of oil palms on their land. Smallholders were also obliged to buy fertilizer and pesticide from the company, pay for transport of their palm kernel to the processing mill, as well as a monthly “management fee”.
The company deducts these ‘costs’ from the farmers’ income. In the end, most smallholders receive only a fraction - often no more than 10% - of what they were initially promised, falling far below the average national income and even below the poverty line. The impact on their livelihoods is dramatic. Some farmers have been forced to find work labouring on the company’s plantation because their smallholding does not provide enough income to feed their families and they can no longer grow enough food because their farm has been replaced by the oil palms.
Environmental impacts of palm oil plantations
But the impacts are not only financial. The villagers showed Roos and Michael the empty plots of land that used to be rice paddies. They have been abandoned since the watershed dried out and the land became too contaminated from pesticide and fertilizer run-off to grow food. In one part of Kiungkang, the water is no longer safe to drink or use for washing.
Farmer and village-council representative Abang explains in this short video the consequences of palm oil in his village:
While there is disagreement within the village about what has to be done, the shared attitude is that the arrival of the palm oil company turned the lives of the villagers upside down. Nevertheless, many villagers are afraid to protest against the company because they now depend on working on the palm oil plantation and can’t afford to lose their jobs. The government doesn’t help them; the letters that informed their representatives of the problems caused by the oil palm plantation have been ignored for years.
Looking for solutions
Both ENDS and Link-AR Borneo are now looking into the options offered by the RSPO’s Complaints System. Although PT SML is not a member of the RSPO (Round Table on Sustainable Palm Oil), it is understood that they supply to RSPO-member Wilmar International, the world’s largest palm oil producer and a major supplier of companies like Unilever. Verifying that supply-chain link is not always easy, which is why it is important that local organisations like Link-AR Borneo support communities to investigate the options available for raising their concerns.
In Kiungkang, Link-AR Borneo is also helping smallholders understand and review their agreements with PT SML to see whether there are any possibilities to renegotiate or terminate the arrangements. Many smallholders are kept in the dark about the formal nature of their relationship with the company and what their options are.
At the same time, it is important to offer alternative livelihoods that decrease the community’s dependence on palm oil. Therefore, a key focus of Link-AR Borneo’s work, supported by Both ENDS, is strengthening the economic resilience of rural communities by promoting trade in non-timber forest products (NTFPs) and social-forestry practices.
We do this through the NTFP-Exchange Program and our Rich Forests initiative, which emphasise the need for community capacity-building and empowerment, especially for women, to bolster the role of alternative, sustainable livelihoods for rural and forest-dwelling communities. At the same time, Both ENDS works with local organisations to ensure that forest areas from which NTFPs are derived are protected, conserved, and managed in a sustainable way.
The problems around palm oil in pictures
Abandoned rice paddy in between the oil palms
Chemicals from the plantation have polluted the water
The bill from a palmoil smallholding. Of the gross income (pendapatan kotor) of more than 1,1 million rupiah the farmer should get in two parts, only a net income (pendapatan bersih) of 113 thousand rupiah (about € 7,50) remains after all costs have been deducted
The solution in pictures: NTFPs
production of handicraft
harvesting of wild honey high up in the trees (l) and the 'beekeeper' with his harvest on the boat (r)
Read more about this subject
The production of palm oil is causing social and environmental problems worldwide. Both ENDS is working to make the sector fairer and more sustainable and is promoting alternatives for palm oil.
Rich Forests promotes a sustainable and future-proof production system and supports, among other things, the transformation of degraded land into food forests. With this, people provide for their livelihood, increase their income and at the same time restore soil and biodiversity.
Video / 30 June 2017
Farmer in Kiungkang, West-Kalimantan, talks about the effects of the palm oil plantation around his village on food production and the health of the population.
Video / 18 November 2013
Between 2010 and 2013, Both ENDS, together with Indonesian and Dutch organisations and universities, conducted a project in the district of Sanggau in West-Kalimantan, on the island of Borneo, Indonesia. The project was meant to help local communities with the recognition of their land rights and. This is a beautiful short documentary about how the people of one of these villages responded to the ever expanding palm oil plantations around them.
News / 5 September 2016
By 2020, the EU wants a larger percentage of fuel used for transportation to consist of renewable sources, such as biofuel. Many European countries have therefore made the blending of biofuels in diesel and gasoline mandatory. A large proportion of this biofuel is now palm oil.
Blog / 29 January 2018By Michael Rice
Pak Japin is a quiet, slim, and softly-spoken man from the village of Silat Hulu, West Kalimantan, Indonesia. I met him at a recent documentary screening in Bali on the fringe of the Round Table for Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO) annual conference, where he spoke about his community's nine year-long conflict with palm oil company Golden Agri Resources Ltd (GAR).
News / 8 December 2015
Both ENDS has, as a member of the RSPO, participated in a dialogue with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. The Netherlands is the largest importer of palm oil in Europe and wants to promote sustainable trade and production chains.
News / 23 November 2018
The production of palm oil is often accompanied by deforestation, environmental destruction and land grabbing. Local communities and activists who stand up against these problems are often threatened. Now the RSPO has taken significant steps in recent months to tackle these issues.
News / 15 May 2018
Both ENDS and Forest Peoples Program have formally requested the European Parliament, Commission and Council and the EU Commissioner for Trade, Cecilia Malmström, to consult indigenous and local communities impacted by EU trade in palm oil and other agricultural commodities in formal EU policy deliberations on these topics. Why did we decide to do so and what's it all about? Our colleague Michael Rice sheds some light on the matter.
News / 24 October 2017
On 30 September 2017 Both ENDS submitted a position statement on the draft Indonesian Sustainable Palm Oil National Action Plan. The draft National Action Plan purports to represent a blue print for improving the sustainability of the Indonesian palm oil industry. However, Both ENDS has significant concerns about the logic, rationale and purpose behind the draft National Action Plan and its legitimacy as a benchmark for a sustainable palm oil industry.
News / 14 June 2019
Last Thursday June 13, Rahmawati Retno Winarni of TUK, an Indonesian partner organisation of Both ENDS, presented a symbolic tree and an appeal to the Dutch Minister of Agriculture Carola Schouten, also on behalf of 10 NGOs. The joint NGOs are pushing the EU, including the Dutch government, for strict EU legislation to prevent the destruction of forests and ecosystems and to protect human rights.
News / 28 June 2018
Last week, indigenous leaders from various countries were in Paris to urge action on deforestation and human rights abuses at the multi-stakeholder meeting of the Amsterdam Declarations Partnership. The group, invited by Forests Peoples Programme and Both ENDS, presented a publication 'Supply chain solutions for people and forests' containing a set of practical recommendations from local communities on how to make supply chains more sustainable and fair.
Participatory Land Use Planning (PLUP) is a rights-based approach ensuring inclusive and gender-responsive land governance, especially for those whose rights to land are not fully acknowledged.
Video / 3 May 2017
This short video is an introduction to 'Rich Forests, a Dutch initiative aiming to promote food forests or 'analog forestry' all over the world, together with working together with local partner organisations.
News / 10 February 2020
Civil society organisations from around the world condemn the statements by representatives of palm oil companies during a meeting with the Malaysian government. In this meeting, the company representatives called critical NGOs "toxic entities" and asked the Malaysian government to not let these NGOs into the country. Both ENDS' partners have published a reaction in which they defend their right "to expose the realities we face in their communities about the impacts of the palm oil sector".
Together with civil society organisations from all over the world, the Fair Green and Global (FGG) Alliance aims for socially just, inclusive and environmentally sustainable societies in the Netherlands and the Global South.
Both ENDS works with partners around the world to ensure that land is governed fairly and inclusively and managed sustainably with priority for the rights and interests of local communities.
Publication / 1 July 2016
Publication / 22 December 2015
Video / 11 November 2016
Rich Forests' is an initiative that promotes the restoration of degraded and eroded areas in the whole world into sustainable, productive ecosystems, using the so-called Analog Forestry method. One of the many advantages of this method is that it can help to combat climate change. This video paints a picture of how this works, who is involved and what results are to be expected in the short and in the long run.