Half a billion of European tax money well spent in Brazil?
What is the reason behind the European Investment Bank’s 500 million loan to the Brazilian development bank BNDES? The money, paid for by the European taxpayer, comes from the ‘climate funds’ intended for projects to stop climate change. Does this make BNDES the most logical choice? Anouk Franck went to Brazil to find out more about this loan.
Investing in clean energy?
Half a billion euros of development money, you can make many, many investments in clean energy with such a large sum. Both development banks have a strong financial reputation and can count on a great deal of political support from governments. Rightfully so? Does the future of development indeed lie with the private sector, as people say increasingly more often, and if so, do we want the money involved to go through this type of banks? Because I have some doubts about this, I decided to find out what this loan was going to be used for.
Fact-finding mission
On the websites of both banks I found one small item about the loan, but information on which projects are to be financed with it are still not available, even though it has been over a year since the contract was signed. If I wanted to know more, I had no choice but to go to Brazil myself. So in August 2012, I travelled to Rio de Janeiro to the head office of the BNDES. Unfortunately, BNDES didn’t want to discuss the loan with me, since the money wasn’t being spent yet. Luckily there were sufficient other sources of information. Various organisations and consultants were willing to tell me all kinds of things about the way BNDES works.
Larger than the Word Bank
When I came back, I made my analysis: in a very short time, the bank has grown enormously; by now it is even larger than the World Bank. But while a World Bank project has to meet relatively strict environmental and social demands, the rules of BNDES are much less clear. BNDES spends large sums of public money to support local and other businesses and offers limited information about this. The bank often invests in those very companies, sectors and projects that have a huge social or environmental impact, such as big dams in the Amazon and oil drilling near the Brazilian coast. Under the guise of “the green economy” BNDES keeps investing in fossil fuels and controversial megadams like Belo Monte in the Amazon.
Economich growth prevails
Many Brazilians – interested mostly in economic growth – have full confidence in BNDES. Social and environmental organisations, however, expose abuses resulting from the extractive development model Brazil’s government encourages so enthusiastically. And let’s not forget the EIB’s role in all of this. As a European bank, it has to follow European rules, and it has to make sure that international norms concerning participation, transparency, accountability and social and environmental criteria are met in the projects it funds. I really doubt the EIB will succeed to do so in this case.
Money well spent?
And now the key question: can BNDES become a forerunner in the field of climate friendly investing, and is the EIB’s money not just being used to make the BNDES look green, all the while deflecting attention from its polluting activities? In other words: is half a billion euros of European tax money well spent in Brazil? I’m sad to say my doubts haven’t been removed after my ‘fact finding mission’, on the contrary.
For more information:
* Report on BNDES (Anouk Franck)
* Interview with Anouk Franck (in Portuguese) on the website of 'Plataforma BNDES', the network of Brazilian social organisations striving for a transparent and more sustainable national development bank.
Photo: from website International Rivers
Read more about this subject
-
Instalink / 3 november 2024
-
News / 1 november 2024
Both ENDS at COP29: advocating for gender just climate finance
On November 11th, the 29th UN Climate Conference will start in Baku, Azerbaijan. Just like previous years, Both ENDS will be there to advocate for local access to climate finance, and to support our partner organisations in their advocacy work. How do we do that, and what are our hopes (and worries) about this 29th edition of the UNFCCC COP? We asked Marius Troost, who will be joining COP29 together with Daan Robben.
-
Instalink / 31 oktober 2024
-
Publication / 29 oktober 2024
-
Instalink / 29 oktober 2024
-
Instalink / 24 oktober 2024
-
Publication / 21 oktober 2024
-
News / 21 oktober 2024
Disappointment over failure to submit National Biodiversity Strategy and Action Plan
We are deeply disappointed and frustrated that the Dutch government has not submitted its National Biodiversity Strategy and Action Plan (NBSAP) for the CBD COP16 in Cali. This disregard for international agreements undermines the concerted global effort to address the urgent biodiversity crisis.
-
Instalink / 18 oktober 2024
-
Instalink / 18 oktober 2024
-
Instalink / 17 oktober 2024
-
Instalink / 10 oktober 2024
-
News / 3 oktober 2024
CVM trial of Vale Executives over Brumadinho Dam Collapse brings new momentum
Fabio Schvartsman and Gerd Peter Poppinga attended a Securities and Exchange Commission (CVM) trial session, last Tuesday, October 1st. Poppinga was convicted by one of the CMV directors, but the second CMV director requested more time to review the case files, postponing the judgment by 60 days. Victims’ families and supporters will have to keep waiting for justice regarding one of Brazil’s worst human and environmental disasters.
-
Instalink / 3 oktober 2024
-
Blog / 30 september 2024
Of EACOP and tales of a defender in development
The Joke Waller-Hunter (JWH) Initiative creates opportunities for young people in the environmental sector in developing countries to unfold their full potential. By providing small grants to individuals to expand their knowledge, experience and training, the Initiative aims to strengthen environmental Civil Society Organisations capacity and efficiency. Grantee Brighton Aryampa wrote a column for Monitor about his journey to becoming a Human Rights Defender, and his work battling the EACOP.
-
Publication / 24 september 2024
-
News / 24 september 2024
Massive Wildfires Ravage South America
“The fires have reached proportions we have never experienced before.”
Large swathes of South America are currently draped in smoke. From Buenos Aires, to São Paulo to Asunción people struggle to breathe due to unprecedented fires raging on the continent, fuelled by extreme drought, the expansion of the agriculture frontier and rising temperatures linked to climate change.
-
Blog / 29 augustus 2024
Local action for resilient wetlands and riparian lands of the Athi river basin in Kenya
and Kyra Pohlan
Communities throughout the Athi river basin rely on healthy and resilient semi-aquatic ecosystems, such as riparian and wetland areas, for their well-being and livelihoods. These habitats have become ever more important for local communities in adapting to the effects of climate change, in particular the more frequent and more extreme periods of drought and flooding. By conserving and re-establishing riparian lands and wetlands, groups from the Athi River Community Network do not only protect their immediate environment but also contribute to the well-being of downstream areas.
-
News / 16 augustus 2024
Statement on the denial of legal protection by the Philippines Court of Appeals towards environmental defenders Jonila Castro and Jhed Tamano
Both ENDS expresses its profound concern over the recent decision by the Philippines Court of Appeals to deny legal protection to Jonila Castro and Jhed Tamano against unlawful harassment and reprisals from state forces. Castro and Jhed are two young environmental human rights defenders who were violently abducted by Filipino armed forces in September 2023, for almost 17 days, in a case that made international headlines. The two women had been working as community organizers in Northern Manila Bay, where large-scale land reclamation's have wreaked havoc on communities and ecosystems.
-
Letter / 22 juli 2024
Joint Call to Action: International Civil Society Demands Justice for Berta Cáceres' Murder Victims in Honduras
This is a joint call to action by international civil society organizations to call upon the Honduran authorities to ensure there is justice for the victims of the murder on Berta Caceres. Eight years and four months have passed since the crime against Berta and the Honduran justice system has not confirmed the sentences of those convicted and has not prosecuted the intellectual authors. We are extremely concerned that independent administration of justice and international agreements on human rights are not being upheld.