Half a billion of European tax money well spent in Brazil?
What is the reason behind the European Investment Bank’s 500 million loan to the Brazilian development bank BNDES? The money, paid for by the European taxpayer, comes from the ‘climate funds’ intended for projects to stop climate change. Does this make BNDES the most logical choice? Anouk Franck went to Brazil to find out more about this loan.
Investing in clean energy?
Half a billion euros of development money, you can make many, many investments in clean energy with such a large sum. Both development banks have a strong financial reputation and can count on a great deal of political support from governments. Rightfully so? Does the future of development indeed lie with the private sector, as people say increasingly more often, and if so, do we want the money involved to go through this type of banks? Because I have some doubts about this, I decided to find out what this loan was going to be used for.
On the websites of both banks I found one small item about the loan, but information on which projects are to be financed with it are still not available, even though it has been over a year since the contract was signed. If I wanted to know more, I had no choice but to go to Brazil myself. So in August 2012, I travelled to Rio de Janeiro to the head office of the BNDES. Unfortunately, BNDES didn’t want to discuss the loan with me, since the money wasn’t being spent yet. Luckily there were sufficient other sources of information. Various organisations and consultants were willing to tell me all kinds of things about the way BNDES works.
Larger than the Word Bank
When I came back, I made my analysis: in a very short time, the bank has grown enormously; by now it is even larger than the World Bank. But while a World Bank project has to meet relatively strict environmental and social demands, the rules of BNDES are much less clear. BNDES spends large sums of public money to support local and other businesses and offers limited information about this. The bank often invests in those very companies, sectors and projects that have a huge social or environmental impact, such as big dams in the Amazon and oil drilling near the Brazilian coast. Under the guise of “the green economy” BNDES keeps investing in fossil fuels and controversial megadams like Belo Monte in the Amazon.
Economich growth prevails
Many Brazilians – interested mostly in economic growth – have full confidence in BNDES. Social and environmental organisations, however, expose abuses resulting from the extractive development model Brazil’s government encourages so enthusiastically. And let’s not forget the EIB’s role in all of this. As a European bank, it has to follow European rules, and it has to make sure that international norms concerning participation, transparency, accountability and social and environmental criteria are met in the projects it funds. I really doubt the EIB will succeed to do so in this case.
Money well spent?
And now the key question: can BNDES become a forerunner in the field of climate friendly investing, and is the EIB’s money not just being used to make the BNDES look green, all the while deflecting attention from its polluting activities? In other words: is half a billion euros of European tax money well spent in Brazil? I’m sad to say my doubts haven’t been removed after my ‘fact finding mission’, on the contrary.
For more information:
* Report on BNDES (Anouk Franck)
* Interview with Anouk Franck (in Portuguese) on the website of 'Plataforma BNDES', the network of Brazilian social organisations striving for a transparent and more sustainable national development bank.
Photo: from website International Rivers
Read more about this subject
Video / 8 November 2019
The Athi River Community Network is made up of communities who live along the Athi River watershed. Members of the Athi River Community Network promised to join forces with the Friends of Ondiri Wetland to ensure that this critical wetland is restored and conserved for the sake of current and future generations.
News / 8 November 2019
On Thursday November 7th, a group of European NGO's including Both ENDS, sent a letter to Vice-President of the EU Frans Timmermans, in which they ask him to support the phase out of European Investment Bank’s fossil fuel financing by the end of 2020.
News / 5 November 2019
After a complaint filed by women's groups from Ixquisis, Guatemala, the Interamerican Development Bank (IDB) has started an investigation on several policy violations, amongst which the Gender Equality policy. This is a unique chance to create a precedent, because complaints on the IDB's gender policy are very rare. The women from Ixquisis are fighting for their rights with support of the Global Alliance for Green and Gender Action (GAGGA).
News / 31 October 2019
Earlier this month, we learned that Golfrid Siregar, an Indonesian environmental lawyer working for our partner organisation WALHI died under suspicious circumstances. We call for a thorough and transparent investigation and have brought the case to the attention of the Indonesian embassy in The Hague and to the Netherlands' embassy in Jakarta.
Press release / 24 October 2019
Press release 24 October 2019
Starting today, investors can use five criteria to test whether companies in the fossil sector are actively working on phasing out their fossil activities. Too many investors still seem hesitant to switch to a profitable future of sustainable energy and these criteria should help them do this. The organisations DivestInvest Network, Sustainable Energy (Denmark) and Both ENDS (the Netherlands) publish the report "Managed Decline of Fossil Fuel Businesses" today, which describes these five criteria. The criteria aim to help investors choose investments that are in line with the Paris goal "stay below 1.5 degrees Celsius warming." The recommendations are presented at the World Pension Summit deliberately, because pension fund investors in particular can take more responsibility in this.
Publication / 24 October 2019
News / 11 October 2019
In Indonesia, US-based mining companies succeeded to roll back new laws that were meant to boost the country’s economic development and protect its forests. This is the level of impact that investment treaties can have on social, environmental and economic development and rights. Why? Because of the ‘Investor-to-State Dispute Settlement’ (ISDS) clauses that are included in many such treaties.
News / 11 October 2019
Indigenous communities in Paraguay saw their attempts to regain their ancestral lands thwarted by German investors. This is the level of impact that investment treaties can have on social, environmental and economic development and rights. Why? Because of the ‘Investor-to-State Dispute Settlement’ (ISDS) clauses that are included in many such treaties.
Indigenous communities in Paraguay saw their attempts to regain their ancestral lands thwarted by German investors. In Indonesia, US-based mining companies succeeded to roll back new laws that were meant to boost the country’s economic development and protect its forests. This is the level of impact that investment treaties can have on social, environmental and economic development and rights. Why? Because of the ‘Investor-to-State Dispute Settlement’ clauses that are included in many such treaties.
Publication / 4 October 2019
Event / 27 September 2019, 13:00
On Friday 27 September, Both ENDS joins the Dutch Climate Strike and the march in The Hague.
This way we let our government know that there is no more time to waste and that it must take significant action in all policy areas to stop climate change.
More information on the Dutch Climate Strike can be found on https://klimaatstaking.nl/english/
News / 25 September 2019
52 charity organisations, community groups, foundations and NGOs, many of whom are not primarily concerned with climate change, have come together to express their concern about the dangers of climate change for everyone and everything in a joint declaration. They call for urgent action and support the Climate Strike this Friday 27 September in The Hague.
Press release / 23 September 2019
Amsterdam, 23 September 2019 - The world's 5th largest pension fund, with assets of over €430 billion, Dutch ABP is continuing to invest in companies that are on a collision course with the Paris climate goals, such as coal and oil companies.
Publication / 23 September 2019
News / 20 September 2019
We are shocked and alarmed by the news of a planned raid into the headquarters of an environmental organisation in the Philippines. Although the raid has not materialised until now, we are deeply concerned for their wellbeing.
Event / 20 September 2019, 19:30
Last June, after months of negotiations in five different 'climate roundtables', the Dutch government presented its Climate Agreement . Negotiations had taken place in a roundtable for 'industry', for 'built environment', for 'electricity', 'mobility' and for 'agriculture and land use'. Climate measures that the Netherlands can take within its borders are pretty much covered by these climate roundtables. But the Netherlands also has a huge climate footprint outside its borders. It seems we have forgotten about the 'International' Climate Roundtable.
Blog / 19 September 2019
Reward high-risk international business projects investing in a green future and stop support for the international fossil industry
The climate is 'hot'. Everyone is talking about it. 'Everyone needs to do something' calls the government in its recently started public campaign. Good plan. Let's really do something. For a start, we can stop supporting international trade in fossil energy by our own multinationals. That would free up 1.5 billion euros which we could use to combat climate change on an international scale and at the same time give our own innovative businesses a boost. Today's Vergeten Klimaattafel (Forgotten Climate Roundtable) will discuss the opportunities for the Netherlands to have a real impact. And those opportunities are enormous. Because our big money and our influence lie beyond our borders.
News / 17 September 2019
On September 20 and 27 the global climate strike takes place. Both ENDS joins the Dutch Climate Strike on September 27 in The Hague. This is why.
Event / 12 September 2019, 08:00 - 10:00
At the UNCCD COP14 in India, which is taking place from 2-13 September 2019, Both ENDS is co-organising a number of side events.
The rising demand for soy is having negative consequences for people and the environment in South America. Both ENDS reminds Dutch actors in the soy industry of their responsibilities and is working with partners on fair and sustainable alternatives.