Guatemala: Why the sugar is not so sweet
I'm in green Guatemala. But despite the idyllic scenery, the green covers a lot of problems. This I discovered during a trip to the sugar cane plantations at the coast.
Early in the morning Victor and Jorge from our Guatemalan partner organisation Utz Che' pick me up and we leave fresh and calm Guatemala-City. The city lies in the mountains, but today we descend to the coast, where it's hot and tropical and where green hills and smoking volcano's define the landscape. The sudden smell of the heat and the vegetation is overwhelming.
We talk about the monocultures that are taking over the region, especially sugar cane. I see the plantations everywhere around me. My companions sum up all the problems. Cutting down the cane is incredibly hard work. Local inhabitants don't want to do it, but the companies recruit indigenous men from the eastern part of the country, for little pay and bizarre working conditions. Jorge explains: "When they arrive here, they first get a medical test to check whether they are strong enough. Working here is hell, they have to cut sugar cane for hours in the burning sun. The men get chemical drinks to keep them going."
To facilitate the harvesting and initiate the process of condensing the sugar, the fields are put on fire. Later that day I will see how giant black clouds rise up from the fields, looking like a heavy thunderstorm. The smoke enters the homes of the surrounding residents. When the sugar cane grows, fertilizers and pesticides are sprayed over the crops from helicopters. The chemicals also effect the crops from farmers on the surrounding fields: these crops mature quickly - too quickly - and often are no longer usable. The chemicals also end up in the villages where people get sick. They want to produce more than the land can handle. The fertile soil is depleted and the Madre Vieja river is running out of water.
The plantation owners have changed the course of the river and use so much of its water that the riverbed has been dry in the past few summers. There was no water left for the farmers around the plantations.
The struggle for water
This morning, we meet with a group of farmers in the South of Guatemala near the coast. Last summer, in February, these farmers ensured that the plantations were not allowed to use all the river water. They talked to the companies and the mayor, who was on their side, and held manifestations. But, as one of the farmers explains, "even when a little water is left in the river - which is enough according to the authorities - the water warms, the fish die and the ecosystem is destroyed."
This year, the farmers want to achieve legal protection for the river. With the help of Utz Che' they will apply for this protection at the court. This will limit the large-scale water use by the plantations. Also, Utz Che' will start a thorough research on the impact of the sugar cane plantations and on the change of the river's course.
Today we will try to find the border of the plantations, which advance further and further towards the coast. Some of the farmers and Dani, the president of the local water board, join us. Officially, the plantations are allowed to plant no further than 3 kms from the coast, in order to protect the vulnerable mangroves. However, we suspect that the plantations have advanced much further.
With the car we try to follow the river as far as possible. A discussion arises: should we only fight the water abuse, or should we also fight against the sugar cane in general? Opinions are divided: everybody confirms that they have to protect the river and the mangroves, but saying that the sugar cane companies should leave can be dangerous. The companies are powerful and people who work on the plantations have accused Dani that it will be his fault when they lose their jobs. Victor explains that for him, it is important to do what the community wants: "I might wish to fight the plantations as a whole, but these people live in between the plantations and have to take all the different interests into account."
weg langs het suikerriet
Looking for the border of the plantations
When we can't drive any further, we leave the car and continue walking, in the direction of the sea. We walk along the plantations, slogging through mud and swamps, get so close to the sea that we can hear the waves, but don't find the mangroves.
A dangerous game
Under the burning sun, we work our way back to the car. The door is open. Did I forget to close it? The windscreen is burst, the papers that we left in the car are scattered around, the rear window is broken into pieces and we find the spare tire in the bushes. But nothing is stolen, not even the car radio. This is clearly intimidation. Whilst nobody knew what we were doing. Who betrayed us?
"They won't scare us!" states Dani. "We will go on because we're machos." Victor takes me aside. "See, this is why it is so difficult here to involve women. There is a lot of violence. Although nothing has happened to us, this convinces the men that the women can't come with us."
Slowly we drive back, looking for tracks in the sand. I'm not scared, just startled. So this is what the people here have to live through day by day, they are risking a lot. What do they feel now? Are they getting more afraid each time, asking themselves whether it's worth it? Or does this incident prove that they must go on, because the injustice is so huge? Is there really no difference between men and women? And would I be scared if I had children? A young man on a motorbike passes by. I wonder whether he's the one who demolished our car and notice how suspicious one can become after such incidents.
"Tell the story!"
This day makes me realize again how complicated such a conflict can be. On the one hand, there is a group of about 40 families who are organizing themselves to protect te river, the forest, their access to water, their land and their crops. And on the other hand are the families who found employment on the plantations: not for harvesting, but for planting, irrigating, driving the trucks or in the administration. Some people who own some land rent it to the sugar cane company. The money they earn that way is often more than they can earn by farming the land. So, big interests are at stake.
Dani wonders what we think about this in Europe. And like so many times before, he asks me to tell the story at home. So people will know where the sugar comes from. So that they will no longer buy it.
Read more about this subject
News / 22 June 2017
On June 5th, World Environment Day, community members at the southern coast of Guatemala protested against the rapid spread of large-scale palm oil, sugar cane and banana plantations in their region. Utz Che', our local partner organisation, joined the march.
News / 18 December 2017
Last month, our partner Utz Che' filed a lawsuit against the Guatemalan state on behalf of some communities along the Madre Vieja River. The communities demand, among other things, that their right to water is respected and that they are protected against water abuse and pollution by large-scale agriculture.
External link / 29 May 2019
Due to their role as environmental leaders, women are key actors in restoring degraded ecosystems. Within the Global Alliance for Green and Gender Action (GAGGA), we work with local women's groups to promote the use of Analog Forestry.
Blog / 10 February 2017
Last month I visited COPINH in Honduras. I stay in their house where I've been before. It has changed.The walls are decorated with colourful paintings, and there are altars for Berta Cáceres, their former leader who was murdered in March 2016. Instead of a simple fence, the building is now being protected by a thick wall with barbed wire. There are security camera's everywhere.
News / 8 March 2019
During the month of March, and as part of International Women's Day (March 8th) and World Water Day (March 22nd), the organizations that constitute GAGGA-Latin America, will lead a joint campaign called "We, women are water".
News / 5 November 2019
After a complaint filed by women's groups from Ixquisis, Guatemala, the Interamerican Development Bank (IDB) has started an investigation on several policy violations, amongst which the Gender Equality policy. This is a unique chance to create a precedent, because complaints on the IDB's gender policy are very rare. The women from Ixquisis are fighting for their rights with support of the Global Alliance for Green and Gender Action (GAGGA).
News / 7 August 2018
Communities from Northern Guatemala have filed a complaint this week against the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB). They bear the brunt of the construction of two large hydropower dams in the Ixquisis region, that are co-financed by the IDB. This is against the bank's own policies on environment and sustainability, indigenous people, gender, and information disclosure.
Together with civil society organisations from all over the world, the Fair Green and Global (FGG) Alliance aims for socially just, inclusive and environmentally sustainable societies in the Netherlands and the Global South.
GAGGA rallies the collective power of the women's rights and environmental justice movements to realize a world where women can and do access their rights to water, food security, and a clean, healthy and safe environment.