How well is the Netherlands progressing in achieving the SDGs?
In 2015, the United Nations instigated the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). These seventeen interrelated goals are intended to result, by 2030, in a better, fairer and more sustainable world in which no one is left behind. As a member of the UN, the Netherlands is committed to promote the SDGs and every year Statistics Netherlands (CBS) and the central government publish reports on the progress made. The initiators of 'SDG Spotlight Nederland' however believe that there is a need for an annual report on the Netherlands' performance on specific SDGs from a different perspective. Fiona Dragstra and Stefan Schuller of Both ENDS contributed to the report on 2020 and tell us here why they think it is so important.
What is the report about?
Fiona: "This report is mainly about SDGs 10 (Reducing inequality) and 15 (Life on land) and how they are related. It looks at the part the Netherlands plays in achieving – or not achieving – these goals at international level. These two goals were not chosen at random, because you can use them to measure whether the Netherlands is helping to maintain the balance between the three Ps – people, planet, prosperity."
Stefan: "And that proves to be disappointing: the Netherlands' efforts on both SDGs are below par: we are obstructing sustainable development elsewhere, not only through the large-scale import of products like soya and palm oil, but also through our continued support for the fossil industry."
Fiona: "And of course that has not been helped in the past year by the Covid-19 crisis. On the contrary: it has not only made painfully clear how vulnerable millions of people are and how unequally prosperity is distributed, but has made the problems even worse. And in the meantime, the Netherlands is failing miserably to take on its responsibilities: the government and the business community do not seem to consider achieving the SDGs a priority, while they are crucial for the transition to a sustainable society."
What is main conclusion from the report?
Fiona: "The conclusion from the report is that, with the policy it is currently pursuing, the Netherlands is not making sufficient progress on achieving SDGs 10 and 15. Ultimately, that can be traced back to the same fault in the system: almost unlimited freedom for multinationals and other companies to earn money on the basis of low wages and the use of natural resources. Our trade system is fully focused on achieving that and our (outgoing) government continues to lend a willing ear to the lobby of companies wishing to strengthen their position at the expense of people and the natural environment."
Stefan: "And the profits made from harmful business activities and in the financial sector are invested in even more similar activities worldwide. In economic terms that may be considered favourable in the short term, but in social and ecological terms it is of course disastrous."
Fiona: "It is a worldwide trend that highly educated people benefit from globalisation and the technological revolution, while people with practical, lower-skilled occupations fall further and further behind. Inequality is thus increasing rather than decreasing, and the Netherlands has no qualms about playing its part in that development."
What needs to happen?
Stefan: "It is crucial that we, the whole world together, work to create a model of economic prosperity that does not operate at the expense of people and the natural environment, but contributes to them, both now and in the future. The idea behind the SDGs is therefore very good and useful, but in practice what is required to bring about real social and economic change is not happening quickly enough."
Fiona: "You can clearly see what is happening in many parts of the world: farming and fishing communities, indigenous peoples and other groups rely for their livelihoods directly on what nature provides, such as forest products, food crops and food from the sea. They have been using these natural resources and products for hundreds of years in a way that ensures they remain available for themselves and for many future generations. And yet they are the first to suffer from deforestation, pollution, soil depletion and acidification of the oceans. All over the world, these carefully preserved natural resources are being exploited by rich elites and multinational corporations. And, unfortunately, the Netherlands is playing a prominent role in this exploitation."
Stefan: "Western countries can play a central role in achieving SDGs 10 and 15, for example by adopting more sustainable eating habits with more vegetable rather than meat protein and many more local products. That transition is one of the main keys to restoring biodiversity and reducing global warming. But to achieve that, the global trade system – which continues to give priority to and promote large-scale production – needs to be radically reformed. Then small, sustainable farmers around the world, including those in the Netherlands, would be better protected. Poorer countries can then rebuild their own food markets and farmers in the EU can once again be paid fixed prices for their products."
So that will call for difficult choices to be made?
Stefan: "The ambition to achieve greater sustainability already exists and cautious steps have been taken in the right direction, but we now need to make serious progress. And that does indeed mean making difficult choices and drawing up enforceable rules to, for example, restrict the activities of the fossil industry. In fields like agriculture, energy and the circular economy, our government is focusing mainly on technological innovation rather than changing behaviour – as in the food transition I just mentioned."
Fiona: "What is comes down to is that we want to keep on living in the same old way. We want to preserve the old, non-sustainable system or maybe push a few buttons to make it a little more sustainable. But if we really want to move towards a fair, sustainable and future-proof world, the whole system needs to change. The Netherlands cannot do that alone but has sufficient influence internationally to play a leading role!"
Where do the opportunities lie for the next government?
Stefan: "There needs to be a national strategy and robust national goals, in line with what has been agreed internationally. And the policies of all ministries must of course contribute to achieving the goals in the Netherlands and worldwide. One ministry must not undermine what another is promoting. At the moment, the Ministry of Agriculture, Nature and Food Quality, for example, may be supporting international cooperation on sustainable agricultural methods while, at the same time, the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Climate Policy is organising trade missions with agrarian entrepreneurs wishing to set up intensive farming and livestock companies abroad. That is incoherent policy and we have to stop that."
Fiona: "The new coalition will now really have to impose stricter rules on international trade for multinationals, that at least ensure that human rights, nature and the environment are given as much weight as the economic agenda. And there is also much room for improvement in development cooperation: local organisations, interest groups and scientists must be involved, much more than they are now, in achieving agro-ecological agriculture and sustainable energy, forestry and nature conservation, so that they fit the local context and genuinely benefit local people."
Stefan: "The Netherlands should invest much more in sustainable and inclusive, bottom-up agro-ecological methods like Farmer Managed Natural Regeneration, which has been successful in the Sahel, and Analog Forestry for food forests. We are certain that focusing on these methods will make an enormous contribution to reducing inequality and achieving a sustainable and fair world in which no one is left behind."
For more information:
The report 'De vrijblijvendheid voorbij' (in Dutch)
Read more about this subject
News / 14 March 2021
A number of our colleagues at Both ENDS made a lot of noise at various locations around the country today, as part of the national Klimaatalarm (Climate Alarm) campaign. Annelieke Douma gave a short speech in Haarlem on the major role played by the Netherlands in climate change and environmental degradation beyond our borders. She made a number of suggestions that would immediately make Dutch foreign policy a lot more climate-friendly. Below is the text of her speech.
Publication / 22 April 2021
Elections are soon to be held in the Netherlands. The political parties are sharpening their knives and have outlined their plans in hefty manifestos. Not surprisingly, they mainly focus on domestic issues. International themes are primarily addressed in terms of opportunities for Dutch companies and threats in areas like health, privacy and competition that we need to protect ourselves against. But if we want to make the Netherlands sustainable, we especially need to look at our footprint beyond our own borders and make every effort to reduce it. In the weeks leading up to the elections, Both ENDS looks at where the parties' manifestos offer opportunities to achieve that.
News / 16 August 2019
Today, an op-ed by Nathalie van Haren and Stefan Schüller was published in the Dutch national newspaper De Volkskrant about the IPCC's latest report "Climate Change and Land". Below you find the English translation.
Publication / 11 July 2019
In 2015, the member states of the United Nations committed themselves to the ambitious Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Unlike their predecessors, the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs), the SDGs recognise the importance of equality within and between countries, of decision-making processes in which all people are included and heard, and of legal systems that are independent and accessible to all.
Publication / 26 August 2020
Blog / 16 February 2021
The Netherlands can contribute much to making agriculture sustainable – nationally and internationally
If the Netherlands wants to make its agriculture and livestock industry sustainable and to ensure that farmers get a fair price for their products, it will also have to look beyond its own borders. The Netherlands is the world's second largest exporter of agricultural products. We have a great impact because, through our trade relations, we uphold a system of intensive agriculture that destroys ecosystems and undermines local production. Partly due to our trade in agricultural products, the Dutch economy is has a large, and growing, footprint. That should and can be different: the Netherlands is in a good position to lead the required transition in agriculture. Fortunately, the party manifestos for the coming elections offer sufficient opportunities to set that in motion. A new coalition can thus take decisive new steps.
News / 7 October 2018
We are very proud that our director Daniëlle Hirsch has been included again in the ‘Sustainable 100’ (an annual ranking list published by Dutch newspaper Trouw), and has gone up more than 40 spots compared to last year! Danielle was included in the list because of the many things she does with her organisation as a whole, but she got the higher ranking for the way she combines her criticism of the destructive role of the Netherlands as a trading nation and large cause of CO2 emissions in the world (often supported by the Dutch government), with a constructive attitude when it comes to finding alternatives and solutions.
Event / 14 April 2018, 11:30
On the 14th of April, Both ENDS wil host a workshop called 'Small Grants, Big Impacts' on the annual Africa day in Amsterdam. The workshop aims to demonstrate that so called 'small grants funds' effectively deliver (devopment and climate) money where it matters, to people that need it the most. Large development banks, funds, donors and governments could use small grants funds as alternative financing mechanisms to make sure their money benefits people and their environment now and it the far future.
News / 1 April 2021
Both ENDS is shocked by the dramatic news in the past days coming from Palma, Cabo Delgado, Mozambique. Our thoughts go to those who lost their lives or who are still missing, and their loved ones. Both ENDS is in close contact with our local partners to support them wherever we can. Many people are still missing, among whom members of farmers union UPC.
News / 16 October 2020
To Eric Wirsiy, director of CENDEP, the importance of forests is clear: not only do they function as a "free supermarket", providing foods and other things to local communities, but they are crucial to make landscapes resilient to climate change and other impacts.
News / 27 May 2021
During the formation of a new Dutch government after the general elections in March, a group of concerned citizens is holding a wake in front of the Prime Minister's residence to remind the political leaders of the climate crisis. On Friday May 28, they will pay attention to the international aspect, initiated by Cordaid, Oxfam Novib, Care, ActionAid, WECF, Hivos and Tearfund. Both ENDS is happy to support the initiative.
Publication / 17 November 2019
Press release / 19 May 2021
Amsterdam, 19 May 2021 – On 25 March, a day after violent attacks in northern Mozambique, the Dutch state decided to provide dredging company Van Oord with export credit insurance worth 900 million euros for its activities in the country. The company is conducting dredging operations for a highly controversial gas project that, according to Mozambican interest groups, is playing a prominent role in the escalating violence in the region. Civil society organisations Both ENDS, Milieudefensie and Oil Change International and their Mozambican partners are alarmed about the situation and have called the Dutch government and Dutch export credit agency Atradius DSB to account.
Press release / 26 August 2020
Dutch pension money is invested heavily in companies that contribute to deforestation in the Amazon region and the Cerrado savanna in Brazil, such as soy, animal feed and beef companies. This is concluded in a report published today by Profundo, commisioned by the Fair Finance Guide, Hivos and Both ENDS. All ten pension funds that were examined invest in these types of companies, with the ABP pension fund and Pensioenfonds Zorg en Welzijn on top with investments worth EUR 580 million and EUR 383 million respectively.
Press release / 18 September 2020
Boskalis doesn’t have to share documents on controversial project; fishing communities will not get crucial information
18 september - The court in Rotterdam today ruled that Dutch dredging company Boskalis does not have to make information on the social and environmental risks of its sand extraction operations in the coastal zone near Makassar, Indonesia, available to local fishing communities affected by the activities. Environmental and human rights organisation Both ENDS had initiated legal action against the company. The court declared Both ENDS inadmissible and did not consider the case. Both ENDS brought the action on behalf of Indonesian fishing communities after Boskalis had rejected repeated requests to provide information on the impact of its activities.
Press release / 1 September 2020
Both ENDS brings legal action against Dutch dredging company on behalf of fisherfolk in South Sulawesi
Environment and human rights organisation Both ENDS is bringing legal action against Boskalis, after the Dutch dredging company continually ignored requests for information on a controversial sand extraction project in South Sulawesi, Indonesia. Boskalis is extracting sand off the coast of Sulawesi for expansion of the port in the capital, Makassar. The extraction activities are affecting fishing grounds, making it impossible for local fisherfolk to earn their livelihoods.
News / 9 December 2019
At the end of November, the organisations WALHI South Sulawesi (part of Friends of the Earth) and Both ENDS filed a formal complaint with the Dutch export credit agency Atradius DSB. Despite the warnings from local communities for the negative consequences of a land reclamation project in the bay of Makassar, Atradius DSB advised the Dutch government to provide dredging company Boskalis with insurance for the execution of the project. The consequences for the fish stock, the beach and the lives of thousands of small-scale fishing communities are severe. Atradius DSB has not sufficiently investigated these harmful consequences beforehand.
News / 19 May 2020
Communities in the Niger Delta have been affected by air and water pollution due to Shell's activities for decades. This year, at Royal Dutch Shell's annual meeting, Kebetkache Women's Resource and Development Centre held Shell accountable for the consequences of their activities. Clean-up of oil spillages and ending gas flaring is becoming even more urgent in the fight against COVID-19, in which clean water is crucial to prevent the spread of the virus.