The 'Right to CO2 emission'
Everything is tradable, even the right to CO2 emissions. In the European Union this has been common practice for some years now. EU countries have agreed to a maximum amount of CO2 emissions, and this 'right' is divided amongst companies in EU countries that produce a lot of CO2. Theoretically, CO2 emissions should be reduced this way. But are they? Both ENDS, together with a number of other organizations, signed a letter calling to stop this system. Wiert Wiertsema, specialist on international capital flows, explains why.
What is the EU ETS?
The abbreviation ‘EU ETS’ stands for ‘European Union Emission Trading Scheme’. The Kyoto Protocol of 1997 obliges countries to reduce their emission of greenhouse gases. Within the EU ETS, companies get a fixed maximum number of ‘emission rights’ which they may either use or sell. If a company needs more emission rights than it has been granted, it can ‘buy’ emission rights from a company that has a surplus. The ETS applies to energy-intensive industries, such as electricity producers and airlines for flights within the EU. When a company would exceed its emission space it is supposed to face sanctions.
What do you think are the disadvantages of the ETS?
In practice, the EU ETS does not reduce greenhouse gas emissions; on the contrary. The emission rights have been distributed free of charge to companies, which in their turn pass the supposed costs for emissions on to their customers and consumers. Polluting companies thus are making considerable profits from this trade in emission rights. Meanwhile they invest very little in smart and renewable technologies to actually reduce their emissions.
Because the ETS is linked to the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) of the Kyoto Protocol, the companies are also allowed to buy emission rights in developing countries. But many CDM projects - such as large dams – have negative effects on local communities, while the supposed positive contribution to local sustainable development is very hard to find.
Moreover, emission rights are too cheap. According to experts emitting one ton of CO2 should cost at least €40,- in order to make a real contribution to effective climate policies. During the last month though, the price dropped to below € 5 per ton. Thanks to the ETS it is much cheaper for companies to buy emission rights than to invest in the technological innovation which is indispensable to achieve a breakthrough.
What would be a better way to reduce emissions?
Almost everyone agrees that the ETS has failed. To combat climate change, greenhouse gas emissions should reduce drastically, there is no doubt about that either. Because it has proven to be very difficult to reduce the emissions at the end of production chains, it is now time to look at the beginning of those chains. We should take measures that will reduce the use of fossil fuels. Effective measures are required to motivate companies to seriously invest in low emission technologies.
In our view the ETS should no longer be part of EU climate policies. The system should be replaced by an effective policy with clear objectives and regulations which cannot be circumvented by companies. Putting taxes on ALL greenhouse gas emissions - just to give an example - would already be a step in the right direction.
Wiert Wiertsema is senior policy advisor at Both ENDS, specialised in the effects of international investments on people and their livelihoods.
For more information about the disadvantages of the EU ETS, read our joint statement:
Photo: Caza_No_7 on Flickr
Read more about this subject
-
Dossier /
Seeking justice for the affected communities of Vale’s mining disasters in Mariana and Brumadinho
In 2015 and 2019, the Brazilian state of Minas Gerais experienced two severe mining tragedies in Mariana and Brumadinho, due to the same mining company: Vale. Since then, the affected communities have been seeking justice, via the criminal punishment of the responsible parties, and a fair compensation for the loss of their loved ones, their homes and their livelihoods. Both ENDS supports local CSOs by amplifying their quest for justice within an international audience and, more specifically, by raising awareness amongst Dutch investors in Vale about the high risks this company’s activities pose for people and the environment.
-
Dossier /
Towards a socially and environmentally just energy transition
To address the climate crisis we need to urgently transition away from fossil fuels towards clean, renewable energy. However, this transition is not only about changing energy sources. It requires an inclusive and fair process that tackles systemic inequalities and demanding consumption patterns, prioritizes environmental and social justice, and which does not repeat mistakes from the past.
-
Blog / 30 January 2025
Brumadinho’s painful “seas of mud”
By Carolina de Moura
Six years ago, Brumadinho tailings dam I, from the Paraopeba Complex, owned by mining company Vale, collapsed. January 25th, 2019, forever changed the lives of thousands. The scars remain open, and the quest for justice, remembrance, and prevention of future mining crimes endures despite all adversities. This was manslaughter coupled with socio-environmental devastation of proportions difficult to measure. These are irreparable losses and damages that could have been avoided if it wasn’t for the greed, negligence, and irresponsibility of decision-makers at Vale, the German certification firm Tüv Süd, and the state of Minas Gerais.
-
Blog / 28 January 2025
Sinking promises in Manila
Yesterday, Global Witness published a new report, "Sunk Costs" - in which I had a modest role to play - that comes up with new facts about the disastrous New Manila International Airport project in the Philippines, for which the Dutch dredging multinational Boskalis received Dutch export credit insurance (ekv) of €1.5 billion.
-
News / 22 January 2025
-
Publication / 16 January 2025
-
News / 16 January 2025
DetoX: Both ENDS leaves X
Both ENDS, along with many other Dutch organisations, is leaving social media platform X. In January, we will join the campaign ‘#DetoX’ by De Goede Zaak and Stem op een Vrouw. We hope that many organisations will follow us so that the hate, misinformation and the undermining of democracy on X are given less space.
-
News / 13 January 2025
New partnership with Netherlands Enterprise Agency for resilient food systems in Sahel
The situation in Africa's Sahel is the world's fastest-growing humanitarian crisis. Over 3 million people are fleeing violence. They are ravaged by hunger, disease and increasing drought caused by climate change. Both ENDS and its partners are successfully working on accelerating the resilience of local food systems and communities in the Sahel, based on ‘Farmer Managed Natural Regeneration’ (FMNR). The project, funded by DOB Ecology, will end in mid-2026, but has already been followed up thanks to a new collaboration with the Netherlands Enterprise Agency (RVO).
-
Publication / 9 January 2025
-
Publication / 8 January 2025
-
Publication / 7 January 2025
-
Video / 6 January 2025
-
Publication / 6 January 2025
-
Publication / 6 January 2025
-
Publication / 3 January 2025
-
Video / 3 January 2025
Dare to Trust: Jarai Women of Cambodia
With the Dare to Trust grant, the Taing Se Malu organization decided to purchase pigs that can be raised and increased in quantities by the women members of their organization. More importantly, through the grant, they formed a women’s group and a youth group to empower them in their pursuit of a more gender-just community.
-
Video / 3 January 2025
Dare to Trust: the Tumandok Women from the Philippines
With resources that the ATBBB women's group received for their Dare to Trust-project, they decided to move forward with growing, processing and selling what they have at their disposal: coffee. They created a production center for their community based enterprise.
-
Video / 3 January 2025
NTFP-EP Asia supports women's groups with Dare to Trust-grants
NTFP-EP Asia has given small grants to two grassroots women’s organisations in the Philippines and Cambodia. These grants are part of our Dare to Trust project, a pilot with unconditional funding supported by the Dutch Postcode Lottery.
-
Publication / 23 December 2024
-
Video / 23 December 2024
Dare to Trust: LILAK supports women to start sustainable agriculture
Indigenous women in Didipio, Philippines, grew close to each other when confronting the mining corporation OceanaGold. Now they continue their struggle collectively in the women's group "Bileg Daggiti Babbai". With the help of LILAK they started a sustainable farming project, which helps them make a living to support their day to day needs and afford their children's education.
The project was made possible in Both ENDS's Dare to Trust project, supported by the Dutch Postcode Lottery.