Is the Netherlands’ reputation as a world leader in the field of water knowledge deserved?
The Netherlands is a major player in the global water sector, but our investments can quite often lead to human rights violations and environmental problems in the countries where they are made. What can a new Dutch government do to reduce the Netherlands’ footprint beyond our borders? Ellen Mangnus spoke to various experts about this issue: today, part 3.
This time, an interview with Simon Richter and Murtah Shannon. Richter is Professor of Germanic Languages and Literature at the University of Pennsylvania, but is better known in the Netherlands as Professor Poldergeist, a cartoon figure who shows in short film clips why countries and cities lying below sea level should be concerned about their future. Shannon is senior policy advisor on sustainable and inclusive water management at Both ENDS.
Is the Netherlands’ reputation as a world leader in the field of water knowledge deserved?
Murtah: This is primarily a narrative that the Netherlands itself projects to raise the international profile of Dutch companies that do ‘something’ with water. It is part of an export strategy backed up by considerable diplomatic, institutional and financial resources.
Richter: “The Netherlands want people around the world to think of the Netherlands if they encounter water-related problems: ‘The Dutch know everything about water, we need the Netherlands, let’s ask them for help.’ They often refer to the historical fight against the water, which they have won by working together. As if the Dutch all agree about everything, which is far from the truth.
With his cartoon figure Professor Poldergeist, Richter tries to get the Dutch to take a good look at themselves.
Shannon: Dutch companies have a lot of technical know-how that can be useful elsewhere, but that doesn’t necessarily translate into sustainable water governance. Sustainability is mainly a question of to what end technical expertise is being used, and who gets to decide. These matters tends to receives less attention, resulting in projects that benefit local elites at the expense of water users like farmers and fisherfolk. In the most extreme cases, Dutch companies have become involved in serious human rights violations and biodiversity loss, as is currently happening in the Bay of Manila for the construction of a new airport - with the unwitting support of Dutch tax-payers. That’s why Both ENDS is fighting, together with its partners, for an inclusive water sector. ’
What does that mean and how can we do things better?
Richter: “It is important that European Dutch citizens become more aware that the Netherlands is also vulnerable. The islands of Bonaire, Aruba, Curaçao and Saba are threatenedbyclimate change. And in the long run, the European Netherlands will also be under serious threat. At present, the Netherlands sees climate adaptation as a business case, a problem mainly affecting other countries.
A lot depends on how quickly the sea level rises – for the Netherlands as a whole, including the Caribbean parts of the kingdom, but also for other countries where the Netherlands wants to be a leader in climate adaptation. If this awareness really takes hold, you would expect the Netherlands to be a champion of rapid decarbonization.”
At COP 28 in Dubai, Richter organized a panel on the dangers and opportunities posed by sand for climate adaptation, the subject of the most recent Poldergeist video. The panel members came from Manila, Khulna and Aruba, all places where Dutch dredging operations are seen as disruptive and destructive for ecosystems and the coastal population. "While the Netherlands is exploring ways to harvest sand from the North Sea without causing too much ecological harm. Shouldn’t it apply the same standards to its activities abroad?"
Shannon: “First of all, the Netherlands should be a lot more selective in terms of who it supports. Companies that contribute to human rights violations or the destruction of ecosystems should not be eligible for export credit insurance, participation in trade missions or other benefits made possible with public money. Secondly, support in the water sector should focus much more on facilitating equal cooperation and knowledge development with partner countries, with special attention to the expertise and institutions of local water users. Cooperation is still too often seen as unilateral transfer of Dutch knowledge to other countries, as if the Netherlands has nothing more to learn. That is simply not true.”
What message do you have for the new government?
Shannon: “The Netherlands should much more actively take on the role of innovator in the field of sustainable and inclusive water management. There is an enormous demand for that worldwide.”
For more information
Read more about this subject
Event / 23 March 2023, 09:00 - 11:00
Online side event at the UN Water conference in New York
This event will present The Transformative Water Pact (TWP), an innovative framework for water governance that has been developed by environmental justice experts from around the world. The TWP will serve as a starting point for dialogue between representatives of the government of Colombia, academia, regional and international NGOs in relation to Colombia's current ambitions in multi-scalar water governance.
Press release / 20 March 2023
Academics and civil society representatives from around the world came together to articulate an alternative vision and framework for water governance, in the run-up to the UN Water Conference 2023 in New York. The Transformative Water Pact was developed in response to the continued exploitation of nature, neglect of human rights and the extreme power-imbalances that characterize contemporary water governance throughout the world. It details an alternative vision of water governance based on the tenets of environmental justice, equality and care.
Publication / 21 March 2023
News / 21 March 2023
Water is literally life, the lifeblood of ecosystems, of nature, of humans. However, in many places the distribution and use of water is unjust and unsustainable. Water management is generally focused on short-term economic interests, on maximizing the profit of a well-connected few at the expense of people and nature. This dominant view of water and water management has its origins in the European industrial revolution, which became the global norm through colonialism and globalization. But according to Melvin van der Veen and Murtah Shannon, water experts at Both ENDS, this view will have to give way to equitable, sustainable and inclusive water management. Both ENDS cooperates with and supports communities and organisations worldwide who are working to this end.
A Negotiated Approach envisages the meaningful and long-term participation of communities in all aspects of managing the water and other natural resources on which their lives depend. It seeks to achieve healthy ecosystems and equitable sharing of benefits among all stakeholders within a river basin. This inclusive way of working is an essential precondition for the Transformative Practices that are promoted by Both ENDS and partners.
News / 15 November 2023
For generations, the people of Bangladesh’ flood-prone deltas have shaped their natural environment to support agricultural production. They used temporary embankments to keep tidal waters out of the floodplains for most of the year and let the rivers flow freely during monsoon season, allowing the sediment to settle on the floodplains as an important part of the delta formation process.
News / 14 June 2021
In Manila Bay, a vulnerable coastal area next to the Philippine capital city, a new airport is being planned, with involvement of the Dutch water sector. Local civil society organisations raised their concerns about this airport, which has large impact on the lives of local residents and on the ecosystem.
News / 14 December 2023
In the weeks following the elections, Both ENDS is looking at how Dutch foreign policy can be influenced in the coming years to reduce our footprint abroad and to work in the interests of people and planet. We will be doing that in four double interviews, each with an in-house expert and someone from outside the organisation.
Event / 23 March 2023, 13:15 - 14:30
The UN Water Conference is an important event that brings together stakeholders from around the world to discuss water and climate solutions. This year, GAGGA is organizing a side event during the conference that you won't want to miss!
On Thursday March 23rd, from 1.15 -2.30 pm, GAGGA will present their commitment to support, finance, and promote locally rooted, gender just climate and water solutions within the Water Action Agenda. This event will inspire other stakeholders to join in their commitment, while presenting inspiring examples of such solutions presented by local women from Nepal, Kenya, Paraguay, Mexico, and Nigeria.
Publication / 15 March 2023
News / 26 July 2021
Both ENDS, together with nine other parties has expressed their concern on the development of a new airport off the coast in Manila Bay, Philippines, where the Dutch company Royal Boskalis Westminster has been contracted for the land development. In a joint letter of concern, different organisations and stakeholders describe the alarming situation around this contested airport that will be built on newly reclaimed land.
News / 23 March 2020
In many places in Latin America, access to clean water is under great pressure from overuse and pollution, often caused by large-scale agriculture or mining. This has significant impact, especially on women. In March, with International Women's Day on March 8 and World Water Day on March 22, they make themselves heard and claim their right to water.
Blog / 2 February 2019
Last week Mark Rutte met with Ban Ki Moon, Bill Gates and World Bank Director Kristalina Georgieva in Davos. They are the chairpersons of the Global Commission on Adaptation, which was also founded by the Netherlands. This is an important organisation because, as Rutte wrote on Twitter, "climate change is the biggest challenge of this century," and as an international community we should "pay attention to the problems of the countries that are being threatened by climate change."
News / 16 August 2016
10 songs: that is the result of a 4 day long, 450 km boat trip through the Pantanal with 36 people. The project Pantanal Poética sought and found a new way to look at the Pantanal, a valuable but threatened nature reserve on the border of Brazil, Bolivia and Paraguay.
Publication / 1 July 2016
News / 22 March 2012
Halls filled with booths, stands, professionally set up corners, wifi-spots. Big rooms where lectures, interactive sessions and workshops are held. People from all corners of the world and from different kinds of sectors (companies, government, and social organisations) are gathering here for five days. They have one thing in common: they are talking about water. The sixth World Water Forum in Marseille is about 'solutions'. For water issues, that is. Almost a billion people worldwide have to cope without clean drinking water.
News / 26 January 2022
Ondiri wetland in Kenya will host the official national World Wetlands Day
celebration on the 2nd of February. This news was received with much joy by the residents of Kikuyu Town and conservationists. For many years, Ondiri Wetland was
polluted and degraded, especially due to encroachment and greenhouse farming. But thanks to sustained and concerted efforts by the residents together with a broad range of governmental and non-governmental stakeholders, the conservation of this critical wetland is now being secured. Violet Matiru from Kenyan organisation Millennium Community Development Initiatives (MCDI), finds it a great honor that Ondiri was selected for the celebrations. "The cherry on the pie!"
News / 13 August 2021
The situation in the southwest delta of Bangladesh is critical. Because of sea level rise, floods are increasing and the area is about to become uninhabitable, despite Dutch-style dikes and polders built in the previous century. Partner organisation Uttaran works with local communities on climate-friendly solutions that restore the living environment and give the inhabitants a say about their future and food production.
News / 22 March 2021
An increasing number of stakeholders in the Dutch water sector are acknowledging the importance of an inclusive approach to climate adaptation. However, where our knowledge institutes and companies are involved in delta plans and master plans, as in Bangladesh and the Philippines, this approach is proving difficult to apply in practice. Taking local realities, vulnerabilities and inequalities – such as those between men and women – as a starting point is essential for good plans that give everyone the opportunity to adapt to climate change.
External link / 19 June 2020
Tidal River Management (TRM) is based on age-old community practices. In 2019, Uttaran helped ensure that TRM was seen by policymakers as a solution to waterlogging in the delta of Bangladesh, and that the voices of women and youth were being taken into account.