Indigenous land submerged by illegal closure of dam
On Tuesday 24th of May the locks of the Barro Blanco dam in the Tabasará river in Panama, which is partly financed by the Dutch development bank FMO, were closed. This is in complete discord with the previous agreements between the Panamanian government and the leadership of the indigenous communities. Last august these parties had agreed that the reservoir of the dam would not be filled until a new agreement had been reached which includes all affected parties. According to the Panamanian government and the company Genisa the present filling of the dam is only a test. But this ‘test’ means that the water will rise 26 meters above the predicted future level of water.
Filling the 103 meter high reservoir will mean the submergence of the lands of the Ngäbe-Buglé people without their consent and some of them will soon need to be evacuated.
For years the indigenous movement ‘Moviemiento 10 de Abril’ (M-10), who represent part of the affected communities, have resisted the building of the dam. The reservoir would submerge some of their houses, schools and religiously and archeologically significant places, as well as turning the Tabasará river into a placid lake. In early 2015 their long protest seemed to have finally bore fruit when the Panamanian environmental agency decided that the works on the dam should be halted after they had to conclude that the construction did not measure up against minimal environmental and social norms.
However, the Panamanian authorities lifted the suspension after the company was fined $775.000 and the construction was completed. The filling of the reservoir is now argued to be the final stage of the construction work under the disguise of a ‘test’. According to Both ENDS and a number of other international environmental organisation this is completely illegal. “Nobody has been properly informed let alone been consulted or even warned about the testing of the dam. Even the Panamanian Minister of Internal Affairs Milton Henriquez now admits as much,” says Eva Schmitz, who is working on the case at Both ENDS. “Via the M-10 we’re getting news of people who are locally protesting these decisions who are being intimidated and were even held for a while by local authorities”. Also the leader of the indigenous peoples who was representing the Ngäbe-Buglé at the dialog table with the government has announced that this goes against all the previous agreements.
Harm already done
The Dutch development bank FMO has invested 25 million dollars into the project and is as such partly responsible for the illegal activities which are taking place now. From a statement on the banks website it appears that the bank has full confidence that everything is being done according to the rules and that there is no reason to panic.
The bank affirms that the reservoir will indeed be tested between the 24th of May and the 3rdof August by fully filling it with water. But, as the bank assures, "the hydropower project will not start operations before an agreement is reached with the local communities, in the so-called 'dialogue table'." An incomprehensible reasoning given the fact that the land and some of the houses of the local people will most likely be submerged by now.
FMO needs to make demands
Cacica Silvia Carrera, who represents the Ngäbe-Buglé General Congress and was part of the original dialogue table, clearly distances herself from the recent developments and states that neither was she informed about what was happening nor does she agree to the filling of the reservoir. It’s not the first time that the FMO is involved in possible abuse of the human rights of indigenous people in Central America. Just last month the bank started to pull back from the highly controversial Augua Zarca project after the murder of the human rights defender Berta Caceres.
In order to prevent the situation in Panama escalating any further the FMO should take up their role as responsible investor by demanding the dam to be immediately opened again and that all the works around the dam to be halted until there is a new agreement between all the affected parties. The bank would also be well advised to, just like they did in Honduras after the murder on Berta Caceres, send a team of independent observers to the location to ascertain the situation in the around.
Read more about this subject
The Barro Blanco dam project in Panama, which has Dutch financial support, is causing indigenous lands to disappear under water. Both ENDS is working to protect the rights of indigenous communities living near the dam.
News / 27 July 2021
In April 2021, the Dutch development bank FMO announced that it is no longer involved in the Barro Blanco project, a controversial dam in Panama. GENISA, the Panamanian company that built the dam, unexpectedly paid off the multi-million dollar loan early. The question is to what extent, now that the bank is no longer actively financing the project, FMO can still be held responsible for the damage and suffering that was caused when this was still the case.
News / 23 July 2021
The million-dollar loan that the Dutch development bank FMO provided to project developers of Honduran company DESA for the construction of the controversial Agua Zarca dam project in Honduras, may be related to gross corruption and malpractice. This is concluded in an article published today in the Dutch news paper Financieel Dagblad, based on information provided by COPINH, the indigenous organisation that has been opposing the construction of the dam for years. Several members of the organisation, including its leader Berta Cáceres, were murdered. DESA director David Castillo has recently been convicted of being involved in the assassination of Cáceres in 2016.
News / 4 June 2021
FMO's new position statement on fossil fuel investments commits to ending new direct finance in the downstream and midstream coal and oil sectors, whilst still allowing for investments in gas-fired electricity generation under exceptional circumstances only. Both ENDS welcomes this development as a step in the right direction.
Publication / 22 April 2021
News / 2 March 2021
Today it is 5 years ago that Berta Cáceres was shot in haar home in La Esperanza, Honduras, for defending the rights of indigenous people. The leader of indigenous organisation COPINH resisted the Agua-Zarca hydropower dam that was planned to be build in indigenous territory. The actual murderers have been convicted, but not so the intellectual authors of the murders.
Press release / 10 February 2021
The Dutch development bank FMO is not sufficiently transparent about the projects it finances and is therefore acting contrary to its mandate. This is evident from a new report published by the International Accountability Project (IAP) and the Foundation for the Development of Sustainable Policies (FUNDEPS), endorsed by 28 organizations including Both ENDS, SOMO, and Oxfam Novib. The research assesses FMO's disclosure and access to information practices for investments proposed between January 1, 2019, and May 31, 2020. Only in 25% of the cases was it disclosed what potential negative consequences an investment by FMO would have for people and the environment.
Publication / 26 November 2020
Publication / 11 November 2020
News / 10 November 2020
The Dutch development bank FMO has published a statement about fossil fuels to take steps in climate action. Both ENDS and partners are pleased that FMO is finally taking a stand regarding fossil fuels, but in our opinion it could be more ambitious. In order to really contribute to sustainability and equality, it is essential that development banks stop investing in harmful fossil projects.
Letter / 9 November 2020
Both ENDS and partners gave their input on FMO's public consultation on Climate Action Commitments and Fossil Fuel Statement. Both ENDS and partners are pleased that FMO is finally taking a stand regarding fossil fuels, but in our opinion it could be more ambitious.
News / 10 July 2020
Dutch development bank FMO is considering investing in the controversial Ficohsa bank in Honduras. The bank has close ties with the elite in Honduras, which holds considerable power in politics, the (para)military and the business community. Last Wednesday, a number of Honduran organisations, including the indigenous organisation COPINH – whose leader Berta Cáceres was murdered in 2016 – sent a letter to the FMO management. The letter, signed by forty organisations including Both ENDS, calls on FMO not to do business with this bank.
Letter / 7 July 2020
A number of Honduran organisations sent a letter to the FMO management to call on FMO not to do business with Honduran bank FICOHSA. The bank has close ties with the elite in Honduras, which holds considerable power in politics, the (para)military and the business community.
Publication / 19 June 2020
News / 16 December 2019
Earlier this month, the seven men found guilty of the murder of Berta Cáceres were sentenced to jail for periods between 30 and 50 years. The court confirmed its opinion that Berta Cáceres was murdered for her role in defending the rights of the indigenous Lenca communities.
News / 18 November 2019
Good news for the climate: last week, the European Investment Bank (EIB) decided to stop investing in fossil fuels by 2021. This is part of its new energy strategy.
Publication / 17 November 2019
Publication / 8 November 2019
Event / 20 September 2019, 19:30
Last June, after months of negotiations in five different 'climate roundtables', the Dutch government presented its Climate Agreement . Negotiations had taken place in a roundtable for 'industry', for 'built environment', for 'electricity', 'mobility' and for 'agriculture and land use'. Climate measures that the Netherlands can take within its borders are pretty much covered by these climate roundtables. But the Netherlands also has a huge climate footprint outside its borders. It seems we have forgotten about the 'International' Climate Roundtable.
News / 30 July 2019
The European Investment Bank (EIB) has published its new policy for energy investments. In the new draft policy, the bank states to stop investing in fossil fuel related projects from 2020. This is good news for the climate, so Both ENDS and partners are happy with this draft policy. The shareholders of the bank, the member states of the European Union, still have to approve it.