Brumadinho’s painful “seas of mud”
By Carolina de Moura
Six years ago, Brumadinho tailings dam I, from the Paraopeba Complex, owned by mining company Vale, collapsed. January 25th, 2019, forever changed the lives of thousands. The scars remain open, and the quest for justice, remembrance, and prevention of future mining crimes endures despite all adversities. This was manslaughter coupled with socio-environmental devastation of proportions difficult to measure. These are irreparable losses and damages that could have been avoided if it wasn’t for the greed, negligence, and irresponsibility of decision-makers at Vale, the German certification firm Tüv Süd, and the state of Minas Gerais.
This article was originally posted on projetopreserva.com.br (in Portugese)
Each person was affected in a uniquely manner by this tragedy. The mother who lost her daughter. The wife left without her husband. The children permanently deprived of a parent. The surviving worker who lost dozens of friends. The community stripped of its identity, its peace, and its river. The local defenders that had warned about Vale’s negligent practices before the tragedy, but were ignored. So many dreams and life plans shattered. Everyone with different memories, sorrow, and suffering physical, psychological, and emotional consequences.
What collective popular memory has been built by the affected population? Which memories will remain from this tragedy? How will this story be told to future generations? The answers to these questions are still in the making and greatly depend on everyone’s critical thinking, responsibility and actions taken. What do you think when you see a sophisticated Vale’s propaganda in prime-time television? Do you believe in the narrative that Minas Gerais state cannot survive without mining, and that we all must accept it as a "necessary evil"? Vigilance is crucial to avoid having your opinion manipulated by those who do not care about you.
For those who have lost and suffered in so many levels due to Vale’s decisions, it is painful to hear statements such as: “It was all very tragic, but Vale has already paid significant compensation and learned from the tragedy.”; “The state signed a multi-billion-dollar agreement benefiting many people.”; “Justice institutions are monitoring dams.”; “It’s time to forget and move on.”
Last week, the activities marking the six-year anniversary of Brumadinho’s criminal tragedy aimed to alert society for the urgency of a structural change in the mining business model. Despite the significant power imbalances between Vale and the affected communities, no one should forget, downplay, or normalize the atrocities and the violations committed by Vale, together with its accomplices and allies, before and after January 2019.
This year, the central message of AVABRUM (the victims’ families association) emphasizes the memories of the irreparable losses. No amount of money in the world can bring back the smell, the voice, or the embrace of a loved one who was murdered.
If the corporations’ punishment is only based on fines and financial compensations, the mining sector will continue its policy of profit over (dead) people. The criminal investigations revealed documents with a budget forecast for a dam collapse: Vale calculated how many lives could be lost and how much compensations would cost—and made its choice. Criminal justice must show that corporations are not above the law and hold accountable those who knew the risks, had a duty to act, and yet chose to remain silent. Only a guilty verdict will serve as a warning sign to all decision-makers in companies who put human lives and the ecological balance of the planet at risk.
The future of the regions Córrego do Feijão and Jangada is another significant question. After all the devastation, trauma and suffering, these areas urgently need social, environmental and cultural healing, regeneration and preservation. The federal government must reclaim the territory by revoking the mining rights given to Vale and its associates and the Minas Gerais state government must cancel all environmental licenses granted for mineral exploitation in the region. The land must return to the people for projects and initiatives that promote social and economic well-being for all.
After more than a decade of community resistance to mining and six years of post-crime struggle, we’ve learned in Brumadinho that it’s impossible to trust Vale’s good faith. Governments and the judicial system must show that they are not aligned to serve and protect the interests of those with the most economic power.
What can be done when companies and governments fail to take action and prevent mining crimes? Resist and mobilize people with art, debates, denunciations, public protests, solidarity actions, technical and political training, research, investigations, and much more. Join a collective and move forward with love for life and a commitment to truth.
About Carolina de Moura
Journalist specialist Environmental Management & Sustainability, Brumadinho resident, and Project Lótus Coordinator, at the Cordilheira Institute, promoting creative economy among women defending territories in conflict with mining. Part of the Political Coordination of the Latin American Network of Women Defenders of Social and Environmental Rights. Regular collaborations with international organizations seeking accountability and due diligence for companies and foreign investors involved in the mining chain, including UN hearings and European Parliament activities. She is the protagonist of the documentary “The Illusion of Abundance.”
For more information
Read more about this subject
-
News / 3 oktober 2024
CVM trial of Vale Executives over Brumadinho Dam Collapse brings new momentum
Fabio Schvartsman and Gerd Peter Poppinga attended a Securities and Exchange Commission (CVM) trial session, last Tuesday, October 1st. Poppinga was convicted by one of the CMV directors, but the second CMV director requested more time to review the case files, postponing the judgment by 60 days. Victims’ families and supporters will have to keep waiting for justice regarding one of Brazil’s worst human and environmental disasters.
-
News / 26 april 2024
Communities Urgent Warning Ahead of Vale S.A.’s Annual Meeting: Stop Ongoing Abuses of People and Environment
As shareholders in Brazilian mining giant Vale S.A prepare to gather online for the company’s Annual General Meeting (AGM), communities from Brazil to Indonesia criticize the company’s track record on human rights and environmental stewardship. They also point to the almost $50 billion in mounting lawsuits against the company as a risk factor that should serve as a warning sign to investors.
-
Press release / 12 december 2024
Website names companies excluded by global investors and banks
The Hague/San Francisco, Dec 12, 2024 - The updated version of the Financial Exclusions Tracker is released today: financialexclusionstracker.org. The website tracks which companies are being excluded by institutional investors, pension funds and banks due to human rights, public health and sustainability issues. The most common reasons for exclusion are links to fossil fuels, weapons or tobacco.
The Financial Exclusions Tracker is an initiative from an international coalition of NGOs striving for more transparency and information disclosure.
-
Letter / 16 december 2024
Urgent call to halt all divestments in the Niger Delta, including Shell's refused sale of SPDC shares
The proposed sale of Shell’s shares in the Shell Petroleum Development Company (SPDC) to the Renaissance consortium, alongside similar divestments by TotalEnergies and other oil companies, threatens the Niger Delta and its people environmental and social well-being for generations to come.
-
News / 24 januari 2024
Both ENDS in solidarity with Justice for Brumadinho!
272 innocent people were killed. A tsunami of toxic mud unleashed, some 12 million cubic metres of ore tailing into the surrounding areas. January 25th, 2024 is the solemn 5-year mark of the Brumadinho upstream mining dam collapse. This was Brazil’s worst environmental and industrial disaster.
-
Event / 29 januari 2024, 14:00 - 15:30
The environmental and human rights impacts of raw material extraction: Lithium in the High Andes, Argentina
Following the Raw Material Week in November 2023 and the provisional agreement on the Critical Raw Material Regulation, Wetlands International Europe together with Both ENDS and the EU Raw Materials Coalition have organised a session seeking an open discussion on the environmental and human rights impacts of raw materials extraction, in and around vulnerable areas.
-
News / 16 augustus 2016
Art as a powerful messenger: music from the Pantanal
10 songs: that is the result of a 4 day long, 450 km boat trip through the Pantanal with 36 people. The project Pantanal Poética sought and found a new way to look at the Pantanal, a valuable but threatened nature reserve on the border of Brazil, Bolivia and Paraguay.
-
Publication / 8 mei 2019
-
Publication / 7 november 2018
-
Dossier /
All Eyes on the Amazon
Covering an area of 5.5 million km², the Amazon rainforest is the largest rainforest in the world. At least 12% of the forest has been lost in the last decades, and deforestation is still continuing at a rapid pace. Illegal logging, land grabbing and intimidation for agriculture, animal husbandry and mining are daily business, and impunity rules. Recent developments, such as the election of the new Bolsonaro government in Brazil, make the future of the Amazon region and the people living there even more uncertain than it already was.
-
Blog / 26 februari 2024
Brumadinho: 5 years without justice
On January 25, 2019, Brumadinho region witnessed a tragedy-crime that claimed 272 lives, including two unborn children, affectionately called "Jewels" in response to VALE’s declarations that the company, as a Brazilian jewel, should not be condemned for an accident. However, the investigations about B1 dam collapse, at Córrego do Feijão Mine, showed that the scar left on the community and environment was not an accident, but VALE negligence.
-
News / 2 november 2015
Not soy, but music in the Brazilian Pantanal!
The Pantanal, in the heart of South America, at the border of Brazil, Bolivia and Paraguay, is the world’s largest freshwater wetland with an extremely rich biodiversity. Tourism and fishing are the main sources of income for the local population. This enormous natural area is invaluable for the water management of a large part of the continent, stretching all the way down to the Argentinian La Plata area, some 1,500 kilometres away. The area faces many threats and Both ENDS therefore already started actively supporting local organisations striving to protect the Pantanal in 1994.
-
Publication / 26 augustus 2020
-
News / 15 november 2018
All Eyes on the Amazon: the future of protecting forests in Brazil
On Wednesday, November 14, Dutch Newspaper De Volkskrant published a joint op-ed by Both ENDS, Hivos, Greenpeace Netherlands and Witness about the deforestation in the Amazon region which is still going on rapidly, having disastrous consequences for the indigenous people who live in the area, for biodiversity and for the climate. The Netherlands is one of the largest buyers of Brazilian agricultural products such as soy and beef, and should ensure that deforestation, land grabbing and human rights violations do not occur in these production chains. Unfortunately, this is not at all the case yet.
-
News / 14 november 2018
Celebrating the River Paraguay
Each year on the 14th of November, in the Brazilian city of Cáceres the 'Day of the Paraguay River' (Dia do Rio Paraguai) is celebrated. This tradition started in the year 2000, when civil society mobilized for the first time and successfully campaigned against the construction of the Hidrovía Paraguay-Paraná. Since then, the date symbolizes the close relationship of the people with the river, its culture and the environment.
-
News / 18 juni 2019
Open letter from more than 340 organisations: EU must stop negotiating treaty with South American countries.
Today, more than 340 organisations from both South America and Europe, including Both ENDS, have sent a joint open letter to European Union leaders calling for the EU to cease negotiations on the EU-Mercosur Free Trade Agreement. The organisations and their constituencies are seriously concerned about increasing violations of indigenous human rights and damage to nature and the environment in Brazil.
-
News / 8 februari 2017
In memoriam: Biu, the last man standing on Tatuoca Island
We grieve over the decease of Mr. Severino Cassiano da Silva – better known as Biu - last Sunday the 5th of February, 2017. Biu was the last native resident of Tatuoca Island in Pernambuco State, Brazil. His life and fate were blended with this island, where previously more than 50 families lived from traditional fisheries and artisanal agriculture and fruit trees.
-
News / 13 april 2015
The Pantanal, the world’s largest waterland, is under serious threat
For several decades, Both ENDS has been closely following the developments in this large water area in the centre of South America. We work closely with organisations which aim to ensure that the local population knows about these developments and, if necessary, protect it from these changes. But why is this area both so special and important for the whole of South America? And what exactly is threatening this area? C. Cornell Evers, independent photographer and writer, spoke with Tamara Mohr of Both ENDS and Sander van Andel of IUCN to find answers. The result of this meeting is an interesting interview.
-
News / 15 juni 2023
Biocultural corridors to restore the La Plata Basin
Even a region like the South American La Plata Basin, known for it's majestic rivers and wetlands, is struggling with drought. A group of organisations united in the Wetlands without Borders network strive to turn the tide.
-
Blog / 26 februari 2024
Impacts of the fossil fuel sector in Guanabara Bay
Last September, together with our Brazilian partner FASE, Marius Troost of Both ENDS visited Guanabara Bay (near Rio de Janeiro) to map the impacts of the fossil fuel sector there. During the trip, he was struck by the braveness and fearlessness of the local fisherfolk who protest the injustices faced by the people who live around Guanabara Bay and about the damage done to the environment.