EU Free Trade Agreements and the Undermining of Agroecology in Brazil, Kenya, and Indonesia
In Kenya, saving and exchanging uncertified seeds is now a criminal offence, punishable by fines of up to KSh 1 million (around €6,500) and up to two years in prison. The laws behind these penalties were shaped by intellectual property rules that the EU has consistently promoted through its trade agreements.
This is not just a Kenyan story. It is a trade policy story.
Today, Both ENDS publishes Traded Away: EU Free Trade Agreements and the Undermining of Agroecology in Brazil, Kenya, and Indonesia. The report shows how EU trade agreements with these three countries undermine the conditions needed for agroecological food systems to thrive. Developed together with researchers and partner organisations in all three countries, the report builds on decades of work linking local realities to the global rules that shape them.
Three agreements
The analysis focuses on three agreements: the EU-Kenya Economic Partnership Agreement (EPA), the EU-Mercosur Association Agreement, and the EU-Indonesia Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement (CEPA). While often presented as voluntary partnerships, these agreements were negotiated under unequal conditions and leave limited room for countries to shape the rules on their own terms.
The report identifies three ways in which these agreements restrict agroecological transitions:
- Seed sovereignty is weakened. Intellectual property rules aligned with UPOV 1991 restrict farmers’ rights to save and exchange seeds, strengthening corporate control over seed systems.
- Public procurement space is reduced. Governments face growing limitations in using public purchasing programmes to support local and agroecological producers.
- Sustainability commitments lack enforcement. While trade rules are legally binding, environmental and climate commitments remain largely voluntary.
Taken together, these provisions form a trade architecture that favours agribusiness, narrows policy space for governments, and makes it harder to support the farming systems that are already delivering food security, biodiversity, and climate resilience.
The report’s central message is clear: agroecology works. Across Brazil, Kenya, and Indonesia, farming communities are already building diverse, locally adapted food systems that reduce dependence on external inputs and strengthen resilience. Yet EU trade policy continues to reward export-oriented monocultures and corporate control rather than protecting the conditions these alternatives need to grow.
The question is no longer whether agroecology is a viable solution. The question is whether the EU is willing to stop exporting rules that make it structurally harder to practise and scale.
The report was developed in close collaboration with researchers and partners from Brazil, Kenya, and Indonesia.
Join our webinar
What do these trade agreements mean for farmers, food sovereignty, and the future of agroecology? Join us on 30 June for the launch webinar of Traded Away, where researchers and partners from Brazil, Kenya, Indonesia, and Europe will discuss the report's findings and explore what they mean for policy and practice.
Details
Date: 30 June
- 15:00 CET
- 10:00 Brasília
- 16:00 Nairobi
- 20:00 Jakarta
Speakers
Speakers include lead author Fernando Hernandez (Both ENDS) alongside co-authors:
- Brazil — Priscilla Papagiannis Torres
- Kenya — Africa Kiiza
- Indonesia — Arieska Kurniawaty
Read more about this subject
-
Dossier /Finance for agroecology
The lion's share of public budgets for climate, agriculture and development still goes to conventional agroindustrial projects that contribute to the current climate, food and biodiversity crises. Both ENDS and our partners are calling for a transition to agroecological practices that are people- and environment-friendly.
-
Dossier /Trade agreements
International trade agreements often have far-reaching consequences not only for the economy of a country, but also for people and the environment. It is primarily the most vulnerable groups who suffer most from these agreements.
-
News / 5 november 2025Another ISDS claim hits the Netherlands: Petrogas sues over solidarity contribution and royalty regulations
SOMO and Both ENDS strongly condemn the newly revealed investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) case filed by Petrogas, an Omani oil and gas company operating two shallow-water gas fields in the Dutch North Sea, against the Netherlands under the Netherlands-Oman bilateral investment treaty (BIT).
-
Dossier /Communities Regreen the Sahel
In various countries in the Sahel, vast tracts of land have been restored by the local population by nurturing what spontaneously springs from the soil and protecting the sprouts from cattle and hazards.
-
News / 5 november 2025Interview: Both ENDS at COP30 for Climate Justice and Systemic Change
Both ENDS is present at COP30 to advocate for genuine access to climate finance for locally led, gender-just climate solutions and the mechanisms that facilitate this, including those for farmer-led restoration. Furthermore, the organisation participates to ensure the crucial connection between the climate negotiations and the trade and investment frameworks that shape them.
Learn more about the Both ENDS team at COP30 below, and find all the activities and side-events in which Both ENDS will participate.
-
Publication / 16 oktober 2025
-
Publication / 16 oktober 2025
-
Publication / 9 oktober 2025
-
Dossier /International trade and investment with respect for people and planet
The network of international trade and investment treaties is large and complex. The Netherlands alone has signed more than 70 bilateral investment treaties (BITs) and is party to the trade and investment agreements concluded by the EU, like the EU-Mercosur and EU-Indonesia trade deals.
-
Dossier /Amplifying environmentally just practices
Because of the close relationship with their living environment, local communities often have the best ideas for the sustainable and equitable use and governance of land, water and forests. These environmentally just practices and processes successfully protect and restore ecosystems and address climate change. They are essential in the light of the multiple crises the world faces, but are in dire need of financial and policy support.
-
News / 6 oktober 2025From Entebbe to Accra: civil society is rewriting the rules of investment
By Fernando Hernández Espino and Bart-Jaap Verbeek
Almost a year after African civil society gathered in Uganda to adopt the Entebbe Declaration, the call to transform international investment governance continues to gain strength. From the 6th to the 9th of October, over 50 civil society organisations from across West Africa, including from Ghana, Senegal, Nigeria, Côte d’Ivoire, Cameroon, Gambia, Sierra Leone, as well as from Kenya and Latin America, are convening in Accra to deepen and operationalise the Declaration’s vision.
-
News / 23 september 2025With the undemocratic splitting of the EU-Mercosur deal, Europe is missing the chance to lead on fair trade
Recently, many newspapers have written about Brussels’ rush to finalize the trade agreement between the EU and the South American Mercosur countries. According to the European Commission, national parliaments do not need to approve it because the trade part and the “political” part have been separated. This “splitting” means that the trade part can be approved as an EU-only decision by the European Council and the European Parliament, while national parliaments are sidelined and the political-cooperation part is postponed. Both ENDS and its partners are deeply concerned and are calling on the Dutch government to vote against this outdated agreement.
-
News / 22 september 2025EU-Indonesia Trade Deal Threatens Communities and Environment
On September 23th the European Union and Indonesia concluded their negotiations of the EU-Indonesia Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement (CEPA), a free trade agreement between the EU and Indonesia. Both ENDS condemns this agreement for favoring corporate interests over those of local communities and the environment.
-
News / 11 september 2025EU-Mercosur: Small GDP Gain, Big Question Marks for Farmers and Democracy
A recent report by Wageningen Economic Research (WER) on the economic consequences of the trade agreement between the EU and Mercosur confirms what civil society organizations, policymakers, and trade unions have been signaling for years: this agreement does not offer a balanced perspective for farmers and the environment. Instead, it increases power inequalities and shifts burdens onto (small-scale) farmers. Moreover, the deal risks reinforcing unsustainable practices that complicate the climate transition and addressing environmental challenges in both the EU and Mercosur countries.
-
Dossier /Towards a socially and environmentally just energy transition
To address the climate crisis we need to urgently transition away from fossil fuels towards clean, renewable energy. However, this transition is not only about changing energy sources. It requires an inclusive and fair process that tackles systemic inequalities and demanding consumption patterns, prioritizes environmental and social justice, and which does not repeat mistakes from the past.
-
Blog / 17 juli 2025A disaster for farmers: here and there
The trade agreement with South America is harmful to farmers, the climate, and biodiversity, on both sides of the Atlantic. It’s time to take this deal off the table once and for all, argues Fernando Hernandez, Senior Policy Officer for Trade and Investment at Both ENDS.
-
Publication / 1 juli 2025
-
News / 5 juni 2025Op-ed: New trading partners, but not on the same terms
Since President Trump's trade war and tariffs, international trade has once again been thrust into the spotlight. In Europe and the Netherlands, there are growing calls for new free trade agreements to be concluded as quickly as possible, as reflected in recent opinions in FD and de Volkskrant. But that is the wrong reflex, writes our colleague Marius Troost.
-
Environmentally Just Practice /Analog Forestry
Analog forestry is a transformative approach to the ecological restoration of degraded lands. Natural forests are used as guides to create ecologically sustainable landscapes, which support the social and economical needs of local communities.
-
Environmentally Just Practice /Agroecology
Agroecology is a diverse set of agricultural practices, a field of science and a social movement. It aims to transform food systems towards greater ecological sustainability, social justice, and resilience. Both ENDS and CSO-partners around the world support farmers and pastoralists practising agroecology, both on the ground and in gathering political and financial support.
