The Netherlands can radically reduce its agrarian footprint
In the weeks following the elections, Both ENDS is looking at how Dutch foreign policy can be influenced in the coming years to reduce our footprint abroad and to work in the interests of people and planet. We will be doing that in four double interviews, each with an in-house expert and someone from outside the organisation.
Our first interview is with Karin van Boxtel and Volkert Engelsman about the Netherlands' role in the global food system. Van Boxtel is co-interim director of Both ENDS and an expert on food systems and international trade. Last year, she was co-initiator of a manifesto that calls for a Dutch agricultural policy that also works for farmers worldwide. Engelsman is an entrepreneur and pioneer in biological agriculture, and founder of Eosta. But above all, he is an innovative free thinker. He recently set up the Robin Food Coalition, a joint initiative of businesses and organisations that are already working on the agricultural transformation.
The Netherlands urgently needs to change to a more sustainable food system. How can that be achieved?
Engelsman: "Change depends on a minority of pioneers. There is always a group of forerunners, followed by a middle group and then a group of stragglers coming along behind. Politicians can only make choices if they have a democratic majority. That makes them followers. Many Dutch companies, like artificial fertilizer and pesticide manufacturers, benefit from everything staying the same. If you, as a politician, try to introduce measures to change things, you can't count on much support from them."
But if the government doesn't do it, who will?
Engelsman: "We have to search out the 'hotspots', where the potential for change does exist, such as biological and regenerative agriculture. The battle should not only be fought on moral grounds but also on the basis of facts and calculations. When the real costs of the current agricultural system are made visible to everyone, it is easy to persuade them because they see that every euro in subsidies for the current farming system generates three euros in social costs."
Van Boxtel: "There are increasingly loud voices against fossil subsidies, an argument that is supported by statistics. We also have a lot of statistics on agriculture and it is up to us to use those statistics to reinforce the very simple message that intensive farming and stock-breeding are not the future. We have many examples of how to do things differently, like the future farmers and food forest pioneers in the Netherlands, Cameroon and Costa Rica.'
The Netherlands is a major player on the world stage: we export around 122 billion euros in agricultural products, 30 % of which goes to countries outside the EU. The largest proportion of that is floriculture, meat and dairy products. But the Netherlands also exports its intensive farming system, precisely the system that you say we need to replace. What must happen to bring that change about?
Engelsman: "We need a different narrative. People still argue the 'we need to feed the world's population'. But feeding the world isn't about yield per hectare, but a fair distribution of prosperity. And making the Global South even more dependent on seeds, fertilizer and pesticides from the West doesn't bring us any closer to achieving that. And what do we mean by 'feeding the world'? People or animals? 80% of the world's crops are used for animal feed."
Van Boxtel: "Our international policy – including the trade agenda – supports Dutch agribusiness. But the starting point should be: what do people themselves need so that support contributes to a fairer distribution of food and a more healthy ecosystem? To give one example: embassies play a role in promoting the Dutch seed sector. Yet, in a country like Kenya, 70 to 80 percent of farmers are dependent on informal seed systems, in which they exchange and reproduce their own seeds. Those systems need strengthening. These farmers don't need an even more active Dutch seed sector selling them seeds and pesticides."
So fewer exports. Won't that have a harmful effect on the Dutch economy?
Van Boxtel: "We need to take the lead on the basis of quality and sustainability, and in a respectful manner. By listening to communities around the world and hearing what they need."
Engelsman: "Leadership doesn't start with complaining about others, but by setting a good example. We are already doing that in Europe, by the way. We have the Green Deal and the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive. Companies have to show what their impact is. If they don't do that, they don't get a declaration of approval and consequently no funding. That rearguard battle about this has already been fought in Brussels."
Van Boxtel: "The debate on agriculture in the Netherlands is dominated by powerful players like LTO and Agractie. It is in their interests to preserve the status quo. But there is also 'BV Nederland', which sees the Netherlands as a commercial community and which is setting a good example. That's how a business model should be built up."
Engelsman: "My message to politicians in the coming years is primarily to listen to the pioneers who are already taking action to initiate the agricultural transformation. They need to sit around the table and take part in the debate. We are already taking significant steps with initiatives like the Robin Food Coalition, but our political leaders really should listen to them much more closely. What needs to be done to achieve the transition? What hurdles are they coming up against? Only if we have that discussion will we get any idea of where we need to go and how. The new government needs to break through the current power structures."
Van Boxtel: "We need different forms of countervailing power: not only power that offers an alternative, but also power that shows the way and the power or working together. We need the protestors, the pioneers and the group that gains strength in numbers. We have to keep on joining all those forces together, nationally and internationally, so that a stronger and stronger movement evolves in the direction of fair and sustainable food production worldwide. By listening not only to the big agrarian corporations, but also – and especially – to the trailblazers, our political leaders can give this movement sufficient space to develop and expand."
For more information
Read more about this subject
-
News / 4 mei 2023
18 reasons for a Dutch agricultural policy with an international perspective
Our manifesto "The Dutch Agriculture Agreement reaches further than the Netherlands: offer prospects for sustainable farmers and consumers worldwide" has now been signed by over 70 civil society organisations, agricultural organisations and companies, environmental organisations and scientists from around the world. Below, a few of them give their personal motivation why they support the manifesto.
-
Publication / 24 april 2023
-
Press release / 21 april 2023
Manifesto: The Netherlands can reduce its international footprint with new Agricultural Agreement
The Dutch Agriculture Agreement, which is currently under development, is too much focused solely on the Netherlands. That is the opinion of a broad coalition of more than sixty NGOs, farmers' organisations, scientists and companies that have today sent an urgent letter to agriculture minister Piet Adema and foreign trade and development minister Liesje Schreinemacher. The government's agricultural policy should also aim to reduce the Netherlands' enormous agrarian footprint beyond our borders, by taking food security and the preservation of biodiversity as its starting points. The coalition has published a manifesto in which it sets out how reform of the Netherlands' foreign agricultural policy could be given shape.
-
Dossier /
The Netherlands, the world and the elections
Elections are soon to be held in the Netherlands. The political parties are sharpening their knives and have outlined their plans in hefty manifestos. Not surprisingly, they mainly focus on domestic issues. International themes are primarily addressed in terms of opportunities for Dutch companies and threats in areas like health, privacy and competition that we need to protect ourselves against. But if we want to make the Netherlands sustainable, we especially need to look at our footprint beyond our own borders and make every effort to reduce it. In the weeks leading up to the elections, Both ENDS looks at where the parties' manifestos offer opportunities to achieve that.
-
News / 16 november 2023
Voting with a worldwide impact
Disposable fashion items continue to flood into the country, the nitrogen crisis has brought construction to a standstill and energy poverty is on the rise, but Dutch politicians are contemplating their navels. These are problems that we can never solve on our own. The clothes we wear, the food on our plates, and the electricity that comes out of our wall sockets – they are all produced in global trade and production chains. With far-reaching consequences, both in our own country and far, very far beyond our borders. It would be naive to think that we can solve all these problems through domestic policies alone. And vice versa: we would be evading our responsibilities if we continued to believe that the Netherlands only plays a humble role on the global stage. Latest figures show that the Netherlands is the fourth largest exporter and the seventh largest importer of products worldwide. With the elections on the way, it is time to look beyond our own small country. Because it is also important to vote with a worldwide impact.
-
Publication / 13 november 2023
-
News / 13 november 2023
Recommendations to the foreign financiers of Argentina's lithium rush
To realise the energy transition, large quantities of minerals and metals such as lithium, cobalt and rare earth metals are needed. These raw materials are mainly extracted in countries in the global South, and unfortunately this is almost always accompanied by human rights violations and environmental destruction. Today – also in light of EU Raw Materials Week that is happening this week – Argentinian organisation FARN and Both ENDS publish a joint report on the extraction of lithium in Argentina.
-
Blog / 18 november 2024
The global rise of authoritarian regimes demands global strategies
The global funding landscape for civil society movements is changing, and is increasingly faced with policies that restrict funding streams, limit philanthropic work, and silence critical voices. These are not incidental shifts but part of a broader pattern that erodes the support for those international networks and movements under the guise ‘necessary financial cuts’, ‘aid reform’ or ‘efficiency’.
-
News / 14 maart 2021
Vote for the Climate!
A number of our colleagues at Both ENDS made a lot of noise at various locations around the country today, as part of the national Klimaatalarm (Climate Alarm) campaign. Annelieke Douma gave a short speech in Haarlem on the major role played by the Netherlands in climate change and environmental degradation beyond our borders. She made a number of suggestions that would immediately make Dutch foreign policy a lot more climate-friendly. Below is the text of her speech.
-
Publication / 30 oktober 2023
-
Dossier /
Finance for agroecology
The lion's share of public budgets for climate, agriculture and development still goes to conventional agroindustrial projects that contribute to the current climate, food and biodiversity crises. Both ENDS and our partners are calling for a transition to agroecological practices that are people- and environment-friendly.
-
Blog / 16 februari 2021
The Netherlands can contribute much to making agriculture sustainable – nationally and internationally
If the Netherlands wants to make its agriculture and livestock industry sustainable and to ensure that farmers get a fair price for their products, it will also have to look beyond its own borders. The Netherlands is the world's second largest exporter of agricultural products. We have a great impact because, through our trade relations, we uphold a system of intensive agriculture that destroys ecosystems and undermines local production. Partly due to our trade in agricultural products, the Dutch economy is has a large, and growing, footprint. That should and can be different: the Netherlands is in a good position to lead the required transition in agriculture. Fortunately, the party manifestos for the coming elections offer sufficient opportunities to set that in motion. A new coalition can thus take decisive new steps.
-
Publication / 2 november 2021
-
Event / 27 september 2023, 16:00 - 17:30
The Future We See - Food Systems
What does a food system look like that serves the well-being of people and the planet?
While agriculture and livestock food production in the world have become increasingly large-scale, industrial and ever more efficient for decades, the damage and inequality this food system causes is also becoming increasingly clear. Across the world, more and more people are therefore engaged in alternative, sustainable food production that ensures many generations to come to still have access to fertile, healthy land and clean water.
In this talkshow, we highlight some of these examples and hope to fuel the dialogue about this topic.
Speakers:
- Rosinah Mbenya - PELUM Kenya (via Zoom)
- Matt Canfield - University of Leiden
- Ida Simonsen - Dutch UN Youth Representative Biodiversity and Food
- John Arink - Ekoboerderij Arink (biodynamic farmer)
Moderator
Farid Tabarki - Studio Zeitgeist
Inspired? Join our 'The Future We See' - talkshow on September 28th! You can either attend live or online, quietly listen or actively participate in the discussion - or during the drinks afterwards. We hope to see you there!
Also take a look at our previous session
To get a glimpse of the atmosphere, see a short video of our last session (about economic systems): https://youtu.be/AUNGcROovnc
And to dive in a little deeper, watch this compilation: https://youtu.be/nzuwIREeiNo
-
News / 15 maart 2021
How well is the Netherlands progressing in achieving the SDGs?
In 2015, the United Nations instigated the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). These seventeen interrelated goals are intended to result, by 2030, in a better, fairer and more sustainable world in which no one is left behind. As a member of the UN, the Netherlands is committed to promote the SDGs and every year Statistics Netherlands (CBS) and the central government publish reports on the progress made. The initiators of 'SDG Spotlight Nederland' however believe that there is a need for an annual report on the Netherlands' performance on specific SDGs from a different perspective. Fiona Dragstra and Stefan Schuller of Both ENDS contributed to the report on 2020 and tell us here why they think it is so important.
-
Transformative Practice /
Agroecology
Agroecology is a diverse set of agricultural practices, a field of science and a social movement. It aims to transform food systems towards greater ecological sustainability, social justice, and resilience. Both ENDS and CSO-partners around the world support farmers and pastoralists practising agroecology, both on the ground and in gathering political and financial support.
-
Publication / 1 september 2017
-
Publication / 1 september 2017
-
News / 10 augustus 2021
Opinion: The genie will escape from the bottle if we don’t change our approach to nature
As a response to the latest IPCC report, the directors of IUCN NL, Tropenbos International, Wetlands International, Both ENDS and the Institute for Environmental Security wrote an op-ed about the role nature policy can and should play in stopping climate change, which was published in Dutch in De Volkskrant of August 10, 2021. Below, you find the English translation of the article.
-
Event / 8 november 2023, 20:30 - 22:30
Election debate: The Netherlands in the world
See the Dutch web page for more information (in Dutch).