The Negotiated Approach in Indonesia: cooperating with communities in river basins
A protected nature reserve, better waste processing, restricted mining and participation of local residents in water management: these are the results of eight years of working on a Negotiated Approach to integrated water management in five river basins in Indonesia.
Five rivers and multiple problems relating to the use and management of their water: reason enough for Both ENDS and a number of Indonesian partner organisations to set to work with a Negotiated Approach. The results included a protected nature reserve for fish in the Brantas, better waste processing along the Ciliwung, a rejected application for mining along the Bengkulu, and local resident participation in management of the water from the Lamasi and the Kampar.
From 2008 to 2015, Both ENDS, together with local partners, applied the Negotiated Approach to promote cooperation between local water users in the basins of the Bengkulu, Brantas, Ciliwung, Kampar and Lamasi rivers. The aim was to achieve fairer distribution and sustainable use of these Indonesian rivers.
Disputes arise between the users of the water resources in these river basins, partly because the knowledge of local communities is hardly used, if at all. By enabling all stakeholders to participate in the negotiations on an equal footing, new, fair and creative approaches can be found that contribute to society as a whole.
Cooperating with communities in river basins in Indonesia
Both ENDS works closely with local organisations, networks and activists to promote ecological and social justice. We believe that local organisations and communities should participate in policy processes and should be given an equal position in negotiations on the management of their own natural resources. That leads to fairer and more sustainable management, because they have crucial knowledge on, and a direct interest in, these natural resources, on which they are often dependent for their livelihoods.
We facilitate dialogue between stakeholders to discuss their shared responsibility for protecting natural resources and the risks of not providing that protection. Both ENDS combines local reality with scientific research, with the aim of finding alternatives embedded in the local situation.
Some of the results achieved:
Removing waste from the Ciliwung
In a number of small villages, the communities have been encouraged to regularly remove waste produced by households, hotels, restaurants and other tourist facilities from the Ciliwung river. The local authorities are now open to proposals to support these communities by introducing an integrated waste processing system.
Habitat for fish in the Brantas
Ecoton has developed a Fish Sanctuary Area (FSA) in the Brantas river, with the aid of seven riverside companies, the local authorities of four surrounding villages and seven schools. The FSA not only helps to preserve the habitat of the fish and the ecological function of the river banks, but also serves as a unique educational environment for the local community.
Lamasi river committee
Both ENDS and Telapak helped the Luwu district chief to set up a river basin committee, the Komite Das Lamasi. The statutes of the committee explicitly allow for the participation of local communities in formal policy processes.
Creating solutions together for the Kampar
A joint problem analysis for the Kampar basin has encouraged the local authority, businesses and communities to come up with solutions for integrated river basin management for the Kampar. As a result, the authorities in this area are more open to cooperating with local communities to create solutions for their water and sanitation issues.
Action against mining along the Bengkulu
Our local partner Yayasan Ulayat Bengkulu is now a member of the Provincial Water Council (PWC), which enables them to represent the interests and needs of the community in policy documents and advisory reports issued by the PWC. One outcome of this is the rejection of a mining application by a local authority, which had asked the PWC for advice on the matter. In 2014, a memorandum of agreement was signed between the village of Rindu Hati and the FH University. The cooperation is focusing on creating a legal basis for requesting mining permits.
The IndoWater Community of Practice
At the end of 2014, to improve the implementation and promotion of the Negotiated Approach in Indonesia, especially in relation to local and national government, an informal Indonesia Water Community of Practice (IndoWater CoP) was set up in various river basins by our Indonesian partners. By working together, the members of the IndoWater CoP can learn from each other and develop joint strategies to better influence national water policy.
Read more about this subject
A Negotiated Approach envisages the meaningful and long-term participation of communities in all aspects of managing the water and other natural resources on which their lives depend. It seeks to achieve healthy ecosystems and equitable sharing of benefits among all stakeholders within a river basin.
With our Wetlands without Borders program, we work towards environmentally sustainable and socially responsible governance of the wetlands system of the La Plata Basin in South America.
Participatory Land Use Planning (PLUP) is a rights-based approach ensuring inclusive and gender-responsive land governance, especially for those whose rights to land are not fully acknowledged.
Large-scale infrastructural projects have detrimental effects on local people and the environment, while their benefits are felt elsewhere. Both ENDS is working to ensure that local people have a greater say in decision-making and is investigating the way these projects are funded.
In and around the rapidly growing cities of the Ganges Delta in India and Bangladesh, there is a serious threat of groundwater shortages. The Negotiated Approach is intended to offer a fair and sustainable solution.
News / 5 July 2019
Manila Bay is crucial site for biodiversity and home to over 23 million people, but their wellbeing is at risk due to reclamation projects, which are also part of a large-scale top-down masterplan for the bay. It is estimated that more than 11 million people are threatened with displacement due to land reclamations and related disaster risks. As an alternative, Kalikasan is developing a People's Plan.
News / 4 July 2019
Tidal rivers in the southwest coastal area of Bangladesh have been dying since flood plains were replaced by Dutch-style polders in the 70s. Rivers are silted up, and during monsoon season water gets trapped within embankments. Every year, this situation of waterlogging inflicts adverse consequences particularly on women, as they take care of the household in waterlogged conditions in the absence of men who travel to the city in search of temporary work. NGO Uttaran is advocating for a change in policy and practice.
News / 3 July 2019
Through pollution and water scarcity, communities along the Kenyan Athi River have learnt the hard way that upstream and downstream communities are inevitably connected. In response to indiscriminate impacts on the environment and people's livelihoods, civil society organisations within the Athi River Basin formed the Athi River Community Network (ARCN).
News / 2 July 2019
The water quality of East Java's largest river, the Brantas River, is increasingly deteriorating due to a combination of industrial and household waste. This environmental pollution has a disproportionate impact on women. Yet, their participation in decision-making remains lacking. ECOTON is working to improve the situation.
Blog / 5 October 2018
From the first moment I arrive in Surabaya, I enter the rollercoaster called ECOTON. I'm visiting them to get to know the work of this long-time Both ENDS partner, and have only three days for this. But ECOTON does a lot, and all of it at the same time. Tirelessly, they work on the protection of the Brantas River.
News / 26 September 2018
Good news from Brazil! The National Water Agency (ANA) has stopped issuing new permits for the construction of hydroelectric dams in the Brazilian Paraguay river basin, which is part of the Pantanal wetlands in South-America. The suspension will last at least until May 2020, after the publication of a comprehensive socio-economic and environmental impact assessment that the ANA started in 2016.
News / 16 August 2016
10 songs: that is the result of a 4 day long, 450 km boat trip through the Pantanal with 36 people. The project Pantanal Poética sought and found a new way to look at the Pantanal, a valuable but threatened nature reserve on the border of Brazil, Bolivia and Paraguay.
Publication / 19 April 2016
Video / 5 April 2016
Indonesia has many rivers, but clean water is increasingly scarce. To address the Indonesian water crisis, Both ENDS and 3 Indonesian civil society organisations initiated IndoWater Community of Practice. IndoWaterCoP is born out of concern that the implementation of Indonesian water resource management is failing. It aims to assist Indonesian government to improve its performance.
External link / 3 December 2014
The Indonesia Water Community of Practice (IndoWater CoP) was declared on December 3, 2014 by a group of Indonesian NGOs whose members felt very concerned about the poor management of Indonesia's water resources due to a lack of integrated planning on river basin management, community participation and law enforcement.
Video / 1 July 2013
In this short movie we follow Indian professor Vijay Paranjpye, who has dedicated his life and work to finding ways of involving local communities in the management of natural resources such as water. What is the Negotiated Approach and what has been achieved so far? This film takes us to India and to Benin to show both results and possibilities.